Haha, your conundrum isn't unique! I also ordered the same lip (from a vendor on Alibaba) for $51.42 in the fake CF finish. Its taking quite a while to arrive though. In any case, I've been thinking about whether or not I want to install this 3-piece cheapie or just bite the bullet and get the Ikon CF front lip, which looks better but is almost 10x as much.
I think what I will do is wrap the 3-piece cheapie in 3M pearl white (close but not perfect match to the paint), put in on, and let it ride until it either breaks or I become to embarrassed to leave it on
I do think it looks good in pictures...not sure how good it looks in person. Its just a tad more aggressive than I'd like and also droops down a bit much relative to the factory bumper, which could be an issue on lowered cars.