I used my OEM 18" rims with the Nokian R3's and put the aero wheels back on to increase range, as I noticed a reduction with the colder temperatures lately. I like the look of the Replika's, but have a few months to decide which rim to put on in the spring but planning to use the stock Michelins for summer again.
I have the R3's on my Model 3 now, with the Xice on my other car (3rd season with them). So far the R3 feels more "squirmy" than the Xice3 but seems to have a more aggressive tread, so I'm expecting better snow traction. My M3 is RWD, unlike the other vehicle which is AWD. I think the Xice seems to be very similar to the summer tires, meaning I barely notice the difference in driving whereas the R3's changed the handling on the M3 by a fair bit. Both are great tires, but if I had the AWD M3, I'd lean towards the Xice with better ride and comfort and RWD go with the better snow traction of the R3's - just my 2 cents. I also find the R3's are a fair bit noisier that the stock Michelin's - not sure if anyone else has noticed the tire volume increase at speed?