We have seen that X-Care is often cheaper than the ESA. Exclusions are the same, $100 deductible per visit, 24/7 Roadside, Trip interruption, Rental Coverage (just incase they stop giving away loaners to people outside of warranty)
I would highly recommend considering X-Care. Can save you money.
Hmmm...
For our 2015 P85D which will hit 50,000 miles before its 48-month warranty expires:
X-Care is $4,599 with $100 deductible
Tesla ESA is $4,750 with $200 deductible
... so $150 upfront and $100 per incident (not issue) "savings" dealing with a 3rd party company which in my past experience hasn't been good.
Here's my 3rd party insurance company experience:
Insurance company backing policy on my Audi went
bankrupt and we got 20¢ on the dollar for the claim we processed
before their bankruptcy... and subsequent claims denied since insurer / ESA company no longer existed.
3rd party company who "bought" GM's Protection Plans for our $75,000 200mph / 505 hp 2006 Corvette Z06 denied
EVERY repair unless my Corvette Z06 was DOA due to that defect... and then only authorized GM dealer to do a minimal fix to get it back on the street. 3rd party Corvette ESA provider absolutely
REFUSED to pay local Chevrolet dealers to replace defective our Corvette Z06's LS7 7.1 liter (427 cubic inch) intake / exhaust head which had exotic sodium filled titanium valves that were rattling like a shaken coffee can filled with bolts
until the motor dropped a valve and destroyed our $15,000 motor. YUP... no repairs approved until the motor TOTALLY blew up.
Sorry, but I'm going to pay Tesla for my ESA instead to skip the "middle man" 3rd party ESA provider from weaseling out of their responsibility.
Once bitten... twice shy.
Twice bitten... FaGetAboutIt