I haven’t put a great deal of mileage on my new Y, but I thought I’d post my initial reactions. My Macan S is a 2017 with air suspension. I like the Y a lot, it’s clearly pointing to the future of cars in so many respects, and the electric motor and instant acceleration make it fun to drive. But compared to the Macan, it’s far noisier (road noise) and a far rougher of a ride. And while the Y’s handling is good (cornering), it’s not in the same league as the Macan. The Macan is supposedly going full electric is 2022.. that will make for an interesting comparison at that time. (Y is stealth performance)