Luckily there was no paint damage, I was able to buff it all out with a microfiber towel.
Ive never been involved in an accident before, this is my first time, wasn't sure what to do when the other driver informed me they had no insurance. They asked me how much it would cost to repair, I wanted to tell them the car is in fact totaled but I didn't as they probably would not have gotten the joke. They also offered to pay for a detail but since I had already buffed it out there was no need.
Had there been any damage to the car I would have called the police, but since all of that rubbery residue came off we went our separate ways.