Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Green New Deal

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Incorrect, that is Communism: ( all property is publicly owned and each person works and is paid according to their abilities and needs)

Socialism: a political and economic theory of social organization which advocates that the means of production, distribution, and exchange should be owned or regulated by the community as a whole. There is many freedoms, like movement, speech, ownership, etc.
News flash: USA has a good deal of socialism in its system.
@h2ofun I simply quoted you what the text book definition of those two words are.
If you cannot accept that, then even "capitalism" and "democracy" is meaningless.
 
Who Created the Renewable-Energy Miracle? Opinion | Who Created the Renewable-Energy Miracle?

And here’s the thing: When an industry has a steep learning curve, government support can have huge positive effects. Subsidize such an industry for a few years, and its costs will fall with experience, and eventually it will reach a tipping point where its growth becomes self-sustaining and the subsidies are no longer needed.
 
The planet is in peril. We’re building Congress’s strongest-ever climate bill | Bernie Sanders
The good news is that the $3.5tn budget resolution that was recently passed in the Senate lays the groundwork for a historic reconciliation bill that will not only substantially improve the lives of working people, elderly people, the sick and the poor, but also, in an unprecedented way, address the existential threat of climate change. More than any other legislation in American history it will transform our energy system away from fossil fuels and into energy efficiency and sustainable energy.
Here are some of the proposals that are currently in the bill:
Massive investments in retrofitting homes and buildings to save energy.
Massive investment in the production of wind, solar and other forms of sustainable energy.
A major move toward the electrification of transportation, including generous rebates to enable working families to buy electric vehicles and energy-efficient appliances.
Major investments in greener agriculture.
Major investments in climate resiliency and ecosystem recovery projects.
Major investments in water and environmental justice.
Major investments in research and development for sustainable energy and battery storage.
Billions to address the warming and acidification of oceans and the needs of coastal communities.
The creation of a Civilian Climate Corps which will put hundreds of thousands of young people to work transforming our energy system and protecting our most vulnerable communities.
 
@h2ofun
I think you are a bit confused about your terminology. As others have pointed out, Communism is a system where the state owns (most) everything and distributes resources according to need. Socialism is a system where the community regulates (but does not own) resources and decides how they are distributed.
We should also include Democracy. The US likes to think of itself as a Democracy but it isn't. The President is decided through an arcane process which allows a minority to take control (witness Bush and Trump; both of whom have been unfortunate disasters - Afghanistan and Fascism among other issues). The Senate is also not democratic since it allows small population states to have the same votes as large. Even our House of Representatives is skewed by gerrymandering and voter suppression to be undemocratic.

Like it or not, the US does have many attributes of a socialist government where the community has decided to distribute resources according to need, not power:
- Social Security provides a minimum level of resources to the poor and disabled
- Medicare and Medicaid provide health services regardless of wealth or income
- Food Stamps (SNAP) provide a minimum amount of food assistance
- Education is free to everyone up to grade 12
- Housing assistance is available for low income people
- Unemployment benefits
One could argue that many of these benefits are inadequate (and others would like to reduce or eliminate them) but the fact that they exist means that the US has at least some Socialist elements.

The Green New Deal is an effort to make the US more Socialist by expanding existing programs and starting new programs to improve social support, infrastructure and deal with the climate emergency.
I think it is a worthy cause.
 
@h2ofun
I think you are a bit confused about your terminology. As others have pointed out, Communism is a system where the state owns (most) everything and distributes resources according to need. Socialism is a system where the community regulates (but does not own) resources and decides how they are distributed.
We should also include Democracy. The US likes to think of itself as a Democracy but it isn't. The President is decided through an arcane process which allows a minority to take control (witness Bush and Trump; both of whom have been unfortunate disasters - Afghanistan and Fascism among other issues). The Senate is also not democratic since it allows small population states to have the same votes as large. Even our House of Representatives is skewed by gerrymandering and voter suppression to be undemocratic.

Like it or not, the US does have many attributes of a socialist government where the community has decided to distribute resources according to need, not power:
- Social Security provides a minimum level of resources to the poor and disabled
- Medicare and Medicaid provide health services regardless of wealth or income
- Food Stamps (SNAP) provide a minimum amount of food assistance
- Education is free to everyone up to grade 12
- Housing assistance is available for low income people
- Unemployment benefits
One could argue that many of these benefits are inadequate (and others would like to reduce or eliminate them) but the fact that they exist means that the US has at least some Socialist elements.

The Green New Deal is an effort to make the US more Socialist by expanding existing programs and starting new programs to improve social support, infrastructure and deal with the climate emergency.
I think it is a worthy cause.
One could also make a pretty compelling argument that targeted tax credits that favor big corporations is also a form of socialism dressed up as capitalism. You don't hear those companies who benefit (or their investors) complaining about socialism though.
 
Biden EPA bowing to big oil, at the expense of the planet.

 
  • Disagree
Reactions: eevee-fan
Here are some of the proposals that are currently in the bill:
Massive investments in retrofitting homes and buildings to save energy.
Massive investment in the production of wind, solar and other forms of sustainable energy.
A major move toward the electrification of transportation, including generous rebates to enable working families to buy electric vehicles and energy-efficient appliances.
Major investments in greener agriculture.
Major investments in climate resiliency and ecosystem recovery projects.
Major investments in water and environmental justice.
Major investments in research and development for sustainable energy and battery storage.
Billions to address the warming and acidification of oceans and the needs of coastal communities.
The creation of a Civilian Climate Corps which will put hundreds of thousands of young people to work transforming our energy system and protecting our most vulnerable communities.
And for those of us who spent their own money putting in solar panels and battery storage, who bought electric cars and electric heating, put in their own wells, what do we get? No, let's encourage those who drag their feet and need subsidies to move ahead. As a teacher, I've been teaching climate change for fifty years, but no one wants to listen, no one wants to change their life style, no one wants to cut back. As one climate scientists said, "We're screwed."
 
  • Like
Reactions: h2ofun
Biden EPA bowing to big oil, at the expense of the planet.

Benefit of biofuel is questionable and it's bad for engines. Glad to see this change. BTW, we've moving to EVs, haven't you heard? Or just trolling the administration?
 
Benefit of biofuel is questionable
Let's see - burn renewables, or burn fossil fuels... Wonder which is better for the planet. What is your view on COVID vaccination - questionable? Masks?

If Trump's EPA did this the greenies would have screamed bloody mruder.

BTW, we've moving to EVs, haven't you heard?
Not in 2021 or 2022 we're not. So your approach is simply eliminate the demand for fossil fuels, and there is no need for regulation?? Seems not too long ago you were arguing the opposite.
 
Last edited:
Benefit of biofuel is questionable and it's bad for engines. Glad to see this change. BTW, we've moving to EVs, haven't you heard? Or just trolling the administration?
Did you read the article?

Try this one, about the same story, but with a different headline:


The mandate is clunky, because it's an amount, which results in varying percentages of blending depending on total fuel demand, which also leads to varying costs of the fuel.
 
Did you read the article?

Try this one, about the same story, but with a different headline:
Conveniently ignores (does not dispute) Biden lowering renewable requirement in 2021 from oil-loving Trump's 2020 levels.

Both articles are based on Reuters. First that I linked was the actual Reuters report. Second is a secondary report based on the Reuters information and is about 2022 levels, and does not mention the drop for 2021.

Here is another one from Reuters about Biden paying back the oil industry and lobbyists that own him - and probably pay a fee to Hunter.

Really surprised how many people in this thread disagree with renewable energy requirements - that is the "green" part of the green new deal.
 
Last edited:
Conveniently ignores (does not dispute) Biden lowering renewable requirement in 2021 from oil-loving Trump's 2020 levels.

Both articles are based on Reuters. First that I linked was the actual Reuters report. Second is a secondary report based on the Reuters information and is about 2022 levels, and does not mention the drop for 2021.

Here is another one from Reuters about Biden paying back the oil industry and lobbyists that own him - and probably pay a fee to Hunter.

Really surprised how many people in this thread disagree with renewable energy requirements - that is the "green" part of the green new deal.
Ethanol in gas has been studied extensively and found to use more fossil fuel as well as damage to environment, agriculture. Not Green.
 
Work Is a False Idol Opinion | Work Is a False Idol

“Lying flat is my sophistic movement,” Mr. Luo wrote, tipping his hat to Diogenes the Cynic, a Greek philosopher who is said to have lived inside a barrel to criticize the excesses of Athenian aristocrats. On Chinese social media, Mr. Luo’s manifesto, and his assertion that he has a “right to choose a slow lifestyle” of reading, exercising and doing odd jobs to get by, quickly went viral. Sympathizers shared versions of a belief that is gaining global resonance: Work has become intolerable. Rest is resistance.

The lying flat movement, or tangping as it’s known in Mandarin, is just one expression of this global unraveling. Another is the current worker shortage in the United States. As of June, there were more than 10 million job openings in the United States, according to the most recent figures from the Labor Department — the highest number since the government began tracking the data two decades ago. While conservatives blame juiced-up pandemic unemployment benefits, liberals counter that people do want to work, just not for the paltry wages they were making before the pandemic.

In her poem “The Summer Day,” Mary Oliver asks, “Tell me, what is it you plan to do/ with your one wild and precious life?” My reply, for now, is simple: Sit on the porch. It’s not half-bad. For what is the porch if not a place to chat with neighbors, to marvel at the hummingbird at the feeder, to listen to the wind in the chimes? An altar for cynics, an altar for the erotic, an altar for the future.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.