I'm not going for practical with these choices.
1. 2016 BMW i8 ~$52,500 on a sticker price of $160,000.
2. 2007/2008 Pontiac Solstice GXP ~ $9,000 and not dropping. Who doesn't love a car designed by Franz.
3. Jeep Wrangler
Thing about that i8 is, with its supercar looks, its actually pretty slow compared to a model 3p. When I was turning in my wife' leased x5, I was waiting for them to do the lease end inspection, and was in the dealership. I was standing next to an i8 advertisement and was astounded at how "slow" it was compared to the model 3p I had just bought:
==================================================
With a
0-60-mph time o
f 4.2 seconds the
2016 i8 will impress most critics, but it's not just the numbers but the unrelenting way the
i8 delivers its power that is truly breathtaking.
==================================================
Teslas really change your perception on whats "fast" and "slow" comparatively speaking, anyway. The i8 looks awesome, but I certainly would not want to be driving one, and blown away off the line by someone driving their model 3P with (in the words of
@Rockster " while tooling around carrying five Russian weightlifters and a bag of cement.)
EDIT:
To answer the question, likely an M3, which is what I was going to buy before I test drove the model 3P, which is saving me not only the potential maintenance, but likely 2.5k a year or so just in gas driving it to work and back.