Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Israel/Hamas conflict

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
The Supreme Court reminded Israel this week that no democracy can tailor its laws to protect a sitting prime minister, for no one is above the law; it also ruled that no legislature can place itself beyond judicial review, for the separation of powers cannot be undone. Taken together, these are devastating indictments of the country’s recent past, but also point the way to a more hopeful future.

From an editorial in yesterday’s Toronto Star:

 
From an editorial in yesterday’s Toronto Star:

It’s not entirely cut and dried....Israel’s Parliament is supreme...in other words it’s will can’t really be contested over the long term, eventually the Parliament has to succeed....and the Prime Minister is only part of the Parliament and his power only comes if he can muster enough support to form a majority in every bit of legislation to be passed. At the moment there is a unity Government in this time of crisis.....but each member of the opposition will have conditions for joining...some it might be purely out of the desire to contribute in the war...others will demand political capital as part of a deal...that may include the controversial legislation over the courts. After the war...who knows
 
Israel’s talk of expanding war to Lebanon alarms U.S.

U.S. officials are concerned that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu may see an expanded fight in Lebanon as key to his political survival amid domestic criticism of his government’s failure to prevent Hamas’s Oct. 7 attack, which killed an estimated 1,200 people and resulted in some 240 hostages being taken to Gaza.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: navguy12 and DrGriz
Our defence secretary, Grant Shapps, squaring up to the Houthis, in a frankly very un-British show of aggression:

"...if this continues, as it did yesterday, there will be consequences. And I’m going to leave it at that"

:eek:

 
Our defence secretary, Grant Shapps, squaring up to the Houthis, in a frankly very un-British show of aggression:

"...if this continues, as it did yesterday, there will be consequences. And I’m going to leave it at that"

:eek:

It's unbelievable how much deference and grace the Houthis have been given by the US, UK and our partners. We are wasting millions of dollars using expensive missile systems against cheap drones, when our militaries could easily target their launch sites and logistics centers with less risk and the same cost.

After everything we have seen this past year of Iran supporting Houthis, Hamas, Hezbollah and Russia creating conflict in Europe and the Middle East - I really don't understand why the Biden administration took the Houthis off the terrorism list and still trying to work with Iran on the fools errand started by the Obama administration.

The path to peace does not run through Tehran or their terrorist proxies like Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis IMO.
 
It's unbelievable how much deference and grace the Houthis have been given by the US, UK and our partners. We are wasting millions of dollars using expensive missile systems against cheap drones, when our militaries could easily target their launch sites and logistics centers with less risk and the same cost.

After everything we have seen this past year of Iran supporting Houthis, Hamas, Hezbollah and Russia creating conflict in Europe and the Middle East - I really don't understand why the Biden administration took the Houthis off the terrorism list and still trying to work with Iran on the fools errand started by the Obama administration.

The path to peace does not run through Tehran or their terrorist proxies like Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis IMO.

Drone launch sites could be anywhere and are easily hidden. Unlike ballistic missiles, drone launchers are also very simple. Some drones launch directly from the ground while others have very simple rails they launch from. If the drones being used against ships are the same as the Iranian drones the Russians are using, these are probably rail launched, but those launchers will be impossible to locate.

This is a Shahed drone on a single launch rail
HESA Shahed 136 - Wikipedia

The Saudis have been bombing that region of Yemen for years and there isn't much left.

The problem with drone warfare that everyone is coming to terms with right now is that the barrier to entry into this kind of warfare is extremely low. A force whose reach from their forces was measured in hundreds of feet or meters a few years ago now has a range of effect in the hundreds of Km with weapons that cost as little as a mortar.

Air defense systems evolved into missiles leaving artillery based systems behind because the aerial threat was from manned aircraft. Missiles are usually one shot, one kill whereas guns can take a lot more rounds and have shorter range than missiles.

Few militaries have enough manned aircraft to overwhelm even a modest missile based AD system and those that do are not going to risk their expensive trained pilots and expensive manned aircraft to attack them. Russia is one of the few air forces big enough, but the AD capabilities of Ukraine have kept their airpower stood down to a large degree in that war.

The nature of aerial warfare has changed dramatically and air defense systems have not caught up.

Shahed are slow, low tech drones. I don't think jamming will work with them because they are fairly autonomous once launched. However, I think helicopters armed with infantry automatic weapons might prove to be effective. Every USN destroyer has at least one helicopter. The US could also send in an LHA or LHD with a helicopter air wing. Currently the US only has two active LHAs (5 were decommissioned and the replacements are being built), but there are 7 LHDs active (the 8th destroyed by fire in San Diego a couple of years ago).

Landing helicopter dock - Wikipedia

Landing helicopter assault - Wikipedia
 
  • Informative
Reactions: navguy12
Drone launch sites could be anywhere and are easily hidden. Unlike ballistic missiles, drone launchers are also very simple. Some drones launch directly from the ground while others have very simple rails they launch from.
Understood. Playing whack a mole at launch sites doesn't work. Certainly didn't work for Israel against Hamas in Gaza.

I don't believe all the Houthi leadership and major weapons facilities/assets are in hiding or untouchable. I would think that our enormous military budget and presence in the Region would have the capability to send a VERY strong message and level of pain to cut this out yesterday.

If we can't promptly restrain or deter something like this - what good is having this massive US Navy and military budget in the first place?
 
The Houthis have been harassing shipping thus far. If they cross the line into killing Americans or our allies, I have no doubt that the US military will put a hurt on them in a hurry.

Apparently the Houthi's attacks have already disrupted 20% of total global shipping costing over $200 billion so far. Not to mention all the extra carbon being burnt by tankers having to travel all around the horn of Africa.

Again, if the US and our allies can't deter something like this - are we capable of doing anything?
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: madodel