Gonna get flamed, but in a way, oil is also a renewable.
As consumers burn more oil, explorers simply seem to be able to find more and more of it. Seems like the Earth is continously generating oil. It is not dead dinosaurs or plants, but something the Earth produces.
There are more oil reserves than we had 20 years ago. All the consumption has not reduced the oil in the Earth significantly. We are finding more natural gas than we can use. Often just flare it off as waste...still there is more.
Downside is still that burning the oil still messes up the air, but not sure that it is not really still a renewable. Kind of like trees can be replanted to replace that which has been cut down.
In a strange way, we are really cleaning up the earth, by pumping out all that nasty oil.
Little out of the box thinking.