Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Papafox's Daily TSLA Trading Charts

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
While it's good to know the information may not be the exact percentage, I feel it is still a stable number. While it may represent a higher number than it really is, it does seem that when the number is at or above 50% the share price seems to be manipulated to less than what it should be. If the shorted number is really 25%, well great we now know the real percentage. The important part is if the share price is going to be effect and at what consistent number based on some sort of standard. If Papafox switches things up it might be confusing. It might be best to keep the reporting the same with a note about the discrepancies.
 
  • Like
Reactions: neroden
Papafox, I'm curious how long the short percentage of trading has historically been sustained at high numbers? Let's say we pick 50%+ as a relatively high percentage, has this level ever been maintained for more than a few weeks since you've been tracking it?

I remember the short volume being 50% more during SP ride down to 245ish. Stayed high until SP finally broke 300 so it was quite awhile trading at that percentage. That was also during a time the M3 ramp was looking bad and kept falling short of Elon’s revised #’s so that was magnified in media, along w/ every fire and accident that any Tesla had for 6-8 week period. I suspect that short volume will fall drastically once news of Gigafactory funding is released. Maybe some good news tomorrow morning after Elon’s meetings in China on Thursday.

Also, interested to hear today short volume on an overall low volume day.
 
  • Like
Reactions: neroden
jul11chart.JPG

Today was a busy day in the Teslaverse. Although no earth-shaking news is in yet from Beijing, the ceremonies in Shanghai yielded talk from Chinese officials about help with the factory, and so it'll be interesting to see what assistance might come Tesla's way.

As expected, the broader markets had a rocky day following the trade wars announcement yesterday, but TSLA weathered the storm fairly well (certainly better than most tech stocks today). Volume was extremely low, shorts did nearly 60% of the selling, and so we can conclude that few longs were in a mood to sell.

The shorts are in serious trouble once Tesla is consistently producing Model 3 at greater than 5K/wk, and after the beginning of July shutdown, the factory is clearly cranking out the M3s again. A friend of the shorts who is apparently working in Fremont posted a number of 550 M3s produced yesterday, which translates into something about 3800 cars. EDIT: LOOKS LIKE THAT NUMBER ROSE TO 610 M3s YESTERDAY. 610X7=4270. Today I saw this post in a TMC thread:
jul11lots.JPG

Looks like the M3 production continues to build quickly.

Meanwhile, Papafox was busy tweeting with Ihor Dusaniwsky regarding shorts and TSLA. The conversation can be viewed here If you want to view or comment on Twitter, go to: Ihor Dusaniwsky (@ihors3) | Twitter . Papafox is "TheElectricRoadTrip".

As long as macros don't go nuts, I see far more reasons for TSLA to go up than to go down as Elon negotiates in China and the Fremont factory starts slinging out the Model 3s once again. The shorts had their chance today to take advantage of negative macros and just couldn't get much traction.

Conditions:
* Dow down 219 (0.88%)
* NASDAQ down 43, (0.55%)
* TSLA 318.96, down 3.51 (1.09%)
* TSLA volume 4.8M shares
* Oil 70.84, up 0.46 (0.65%)
* Percent of TSLA shares sold by shorts: 58.75% (volumebot.com)
 
Last edited:
The reason the shorts were able to get some longs worried after Tesla delivered 5K M3s/wk in late June was because with the tent and extraordinary efforts, many in Wall Street regarded making 5K/wk as a lucky Hail Mary pass that quarterback Musk somehow completed. The move to 5K/wk production in the next week or two is going to be an entirely different animal.
 
So, in the other thread, Papafox said he called up his data source and FINRA and found out that the "half volume" is because they're only looking at some exchanges, and that the short sale data is from the same exchanges. So the percentage at volumebot may be right *for that subset of exchanges*. We don't know whether short-sellers preferentially hang out at some exchanges rather than others, however. (There is strong reason to believe they do; different exchanges offer them different deals.)

While it's good to know the information may not be the exact percentage, I feel it is still a stable number.
The absolute value of "percent of shares sold short" seems to be a bit questionable, but we can *certainly* track whether the percentage of shorting is rising or falling, since every data source seems to be in agreement on that. And I think that's very informative. If the percentage is unusually high or unusually low on a given day, it means something.

So, I'd suggest everyone treat the percentage as a relative thing ("more short-selling today" vs. "less short-selling today") rather than trying to do calculations with it as an absolute percentage. As long as we're using a consistent source, the changes should be valid data.
 
  • Like
Reactions: generalenthu
Screen Shot 2018-07-12 at 1.51.02 PM.png

Today was a surprise to me, given the strength TSLA showed yesterday in the down market. I suppose the CNBC 12 minute hit piece featuring Linette Lopez and two Jim Chanos cronies took a toll when combined with no news from Musk in Beijing and media stories that painted Tesla's hitting 200,000 vehicles deliveries in 3rd quarter as a negative (instead of the real positive that anyone watching carefully would conclude). Shorts were responsible for a bit over 58% of today's TSLA selling, which indicates that their efforts have already peaked (see chart below).

Screen Shot 2018-07-12 at 1.59.47 PM.png

Short percentage of TSLA selling today was 58.20% I agree with Neroden that the number we get from FINRA and similar sources needs to be considered a relative number because of matters such as batching of transactions and normal market-maker/brokerage housekeeping. Nonetheless, I'll continue to refer to the number itself as any other approach becomes too clumsy.


Screen Shot 2018-07-12 at 1.47.59 PM copy500.png

Yesterday we learned that short interest was 36.1 million shares, an amazingly high number given that TSLA is so close to going profitable and staying profitable.


Screen Shot 2018-07-12 at 1.56.25 PM.png

Looking at the technical chart, you can see that the blue 50 day moving average is coming very close to the red 200 day moving average and is setting up for a golden cross, which should attract technically-oriented traders. Meanwhile the climb that TSLA had been in has not deteriorated into the descent that shorts have been expending considerable energy upon, but rather we see a consolidation that will need to break up or down sometime soon.

The friend of shorts who claims to have some view of Tesla's production numbers is known as Skabooshka on twitter. His post for today is a Model 3 production rate of 700 M3s, which works out to be 4900/wk. I see no reason why a short would be exaggerating Model 3 production numbers, but any unconfirmed spy number needs to be taken with a grain of salt.

We're getting drone shots of red Model 3s (likely performance editions) sitting outside at the Fremont factory. The performance edition will be hugely important for Tesla because the mix of performance to overall production of M3 vs. MS or MX. The Model 3 is a smaller, lighter vehicle than the P100D and as such is more appropriate for attracting the attention of performance car fans. It will become the affordable Ferrari or Lamborghini for the masses. The considerably higher gross margins on this model of M3 will combine with the large numbers of the Performance M3 purchased to yeild a big assist to Tesla's ability to turn profits in Q3 and Q4.

So, If you're looking for upcoming catalysts, the list includes:
* Golden-cross
* Model 3 spy numbers suggest production up to sustainable 5K/wk production by tomorrow (plus cashflow + and GAAP profitable going forward)
* A possible giga-watt-hr. sized battery farm announced soon in California
* Model 3 performance vehicles available for test rides in week or two
* Model 3 performance vehicle reviews soon by automotive magazines
* Early August: 2Q ER with bad numbers but likely very positive guidance for Q3 and Q4 and confirmation that Tesla has already reached positive cash flow and GAAP profitable numbers in vehicle production
* More than 8,000 Modlel 3 Vins registered by Tesla in past couple of days, with a substantial number for dual-motor production

So, with lots of pressure from shorts, expect continued volatility but with all the good news coming out lately from the Model 3 production side of things I'm going to bet the current consolidation resolves into a rally at some point, rather than a drop (macros permitting).

Conditions:
* Dow up 244 (0.91%)
* NASDAQ up 107 (1.39%)
* TSLA 316.71, down 2.25 (0.71%)
* TSLA volume 5.7M shares
* Oil 70.35, up 0.02 (0.03%)
* Percent of selling by TSLA shorts: 58.22%
 
jul11bloom.png

Here's today's Bloomberg Model 3 production tracker graph. Looks like they're back to their old tricks of forecasting that production will fall way off and 5K/wk isn't close to sustainable. For this reason, give the market some time to digest Tesla's Model 3 production gains. We're dealing with lots of skepticism out there, folks.
 
Screen Shot 2018-07-13 at 1.12.36 PM.png


Today was classic manipulation by shorts. We saw a deep dip prior to 10am by TSLA and the NASDAQ, but the NASDAQ bounced back immediately while shorts did their best to make that dip sticky and on steroids for TSLA. Nonetheless, TSLA managed to find green before noon, a game of whack-the-mole proceeded until about 2:30pm, at which time shorts started capping the rally in an effort to keep TSLA below 320. No less than 107,000 shares traded hands in the final minute of market trading as shorts licked their wounds and covered some of their day's activities.

Screen Shot 2018-07-13 at 1.06.06 PM.png

Percent of selling by TSLA shorts today dropped significantly, to 48.85%

Screen Shot 2018-07-13 at 1.43.15 PM.png

Looking at the technical chart, you can see the consolidation between the 200 day moving average and the 50 day moving average continues. Which way is TSLA likely to break? If you compare the short selling percent with the stock performance, the answer is staring right at you. July 2 is the first day of a big increase in short percentage of trading, and on the tech chart it is the day with 364.78 as the high and the really big dip down from there. In other words, as the shorts cranked up the percentage of selling, the dip that TSLA took was exactly colocated with that increase in short-selling activity. Now, today, we see the first major break downward in the percentage of selling by shorts. To me, this is a sign of shorts becoming worried, realize they can't push TSLA down any more and not wanting to go into the weekend holding too many temporary short positions. I think they're scared of a Monday morning rally, and they have good reason to be scared. There will be plenty of time over the weekend for numbers to leak out regarding the now-sustainable pace of Tesla's Model 3 production.

For the week, TSLA closed at 318.87, up 9.97 from last Friday's 308.90. Model 3s are rolling off the line at Fremont once again at a rapid pace, and the shorts have seen the momentum swing this week despite their best efforts to sink TSLA before a major rally. The significant dip in percentage of selling by shorts suggests fear of Monday, which in turn suggests an upward resolution to the consolidation Tesla has been in. Macros permitting, next week should be fun for us longs. Enjoy your weekend.

Conditions:
* Dow up 95 (0.38%)
* NASDAQ up 2 (0.03%)
* TSLA 318.87, up 2.16 (0.68%)
* TSLA volume 5.8M shares
* Oil 71.01, up 0.68 (0.97%)
* Percent of selling by shorts: 48.85%
 
Last edited:
jul16chart.JPG


Many of us were looking forward to a positive Monday, but alas, some diver from the Thailand rescue tweeted to Elon and said to stick the mini-sub up a certain part of his anatomy and Elon responded by calling the diver "pedo". Elon fairly quickly realized he had screwed up and took down the post plus several others but the damage was done and led to today's red trading day. Hopefully, Elon has learned his lesson. The good news is that volume wasn't particularly heavy today, suggesting this is not a big investor starting to unload TSLA because of an Elon comment of Twitter but rather shorts jumping in (hoping that Elon has flipped out) and some selling by spooked longs.

Consider today's dip a response to something that will not have a lasting effect upon TSLA. Meanwhile, evidence of Model 3 production suggests Tesla may now be producing at a rate of over 5K/wk. According to information released through a meeting of banks and big investors with Tesla last week, Tesla believes they can reach 6K/wk on M3 pretty quickly, 7K/wk before the end of this year, and 10K/wk sometime in 2019. A hundred red P3Ds have shipped to Tesla stores for rides to begin next week, and thousands of AWD VIN numbers have been originated by Tesla in the past week.

The big news today was that Sandy Munro, who had taken apart a Model 3 to evaluate the likely cost of the car, came out with a bullish revision to earlier findings and suggested that Tesla should be able to build Model 3s with a gross margin of greater than 30%. Thus, we have indirect evidence that production numbers are doing great and gross margins will be very substantial, which reinforces Tesla's predicted Q3 and Q4 positive cash flow and GAAP profits. We just need to get through the immediate noise in order for the seriously-positive news on Tesla to become the focus of the media.

jul16short450.png

Shorts sold 52% of TSLA today, according to volumebot.com
The change to an uptrend in percentage of selling by shorts is a direct result of Sunday's Twitter follies by Elon and shorts hoping they can leverage the noise.

Is it time to buy TSLA if you have some spare change in the sofa? Consider waiting to see what the SP does tomorrow, because Netflix had disappointing news at its earnings report and it will likely pull the NASDAQ down on opening tomorrow. If you plan to do some buying watch carefully, because when the noise and macro dips stop, TSLA will be ready to regain lost territory.

Conditions:
* Dow up 45 (0.18%)
* NASDAQ down 20 (0.26%)
* TSLA 310.10, down 8.77 (2.75%)
* TSLA volume 7.7M shares
* Oil 68.02, down 0.04 (0.06%)
 
jul17chart.JPG

Don't you just love it when the winds blow in the right direction? The NASDAQ's concerns about Netflix allowed for a buying period this morning for TSLA before investors figured out that the Munro news from yesterdy was huge news and the name-calling on Twitter wasn't going to be a lasting issue for Tesla. Consequently, TSLA reclaimed all ground lost yesterday and then added some. Nearly 140,000 shares traded hands in the first minute of market trading.

Take a look at the long, level trading just below 315. It looks like capping to me and when the cap was defeated the stock climbed in a big way.

jul7nas.png

Today's NASDAQ chart shows a steady climb from the negative numbers on opening to a very positive close

jul17tech.png

Looking at the technical chart, you can see that TSLA closed above the 200 DMA again and not too far below the mid bollinger band. It'd be nice to get the bollinger bands heading up so that when good news comes forth, TSLA has a clean path to run. Notice that TSLA's upper bb is around 362 now and with known resistance around 360, we don't want the combination of an upper bb and a resistance point coming together to make a big ascent just that much more difficult.For that reason, some additional climbing by TSLA this week would be a very good thing.

In other news, the production numbers put forth by short-ally Skabooshka are now doing what I was expecting all along, which is to say the numbers went above the 5K/wk daily numbers and then have been falling back. I continue to suggest caution in drawing conclusions from these numbers because of their source, and the decrease in numbers might have been the reason these encouraging numbers were put forth, all along.

Anyway, longs, congratulations on a very green day.

Conditions:
* Dow up 56 (0.22%)
* NASDAQ up 49(0.63%)
* TSLA 322.69, up 12.59 (4.06%)
* TSLA volume 6.8M shares
* Oil 67.61, down 0.45 (0.66%)
* Percent of TSLA selling done by shorts: 50.4%
 
Hmmm... Curious: When does all the after hours trading get accounted? Is that why we keep seeing massive numbers in the first minute of trading, or are those statistics and volumes ignored in the daily charts?
No, it's because a lot of people don't like to (and some brokerages don't allow) trade out of hours, due to the low volumes. So they place market or limit orders out of hours, which the exchange totals up, and when the market opens the opening price is determined by maximizing the instantaneous trades (not sure whether maximized for number of trades or dollar value). That's why you get "gap up" or "gap down" type behavior.