Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Russia/Ukraine conflict

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
But how much did attacking these ships help the war effort?

Ukraine has hobbled Russia's Black Sea Fleet. Could it turn the tide of the war?

Russia’s Black Sea Fleet was once considered central to Vladimir Putin’s attempted conquest of Ukraine.

But that fleet and its accompanying air wing have been battered by innovative Ukrainian missile and drone attacks, turning the once-feared force into something of an afterthought in Europe’s largest war in seven decades.


IMHO, crippling the Black Sea Fleet was huge. As big as damaging the Kerch Strait Bridge, maybe bigger. After the naval drone attacks, Russia withdrew it's permission to let grain ships sail from Ukraine. They sailed anyway and then Russia changed its mind. Perhaps Russia lacked the naval power to interdict the grain ships and didn't want to get NATO involved in the war by sinking them with missiles. In addition, the Russia ships had been firing missiles into Ukraine making them important military targets.
 
Lots of indications seem to point to Russia exiting Kherson west (right) bank and blowing lots up behind, possibly including destroying the hydro eqpt at the dam




IMHO it's time for Ukraine to finish off that bridge Putin was so proud of, promote the rest of Russia's boats to Submarine status, finish off the rest of Putin's helicopters, and it's gonna be a shame if anything happened to half the power plants in Russia...
 
IMHO it's time for Ukraine to finish off that bridge Putin was so proud of, promote the rest of Russia's boats to Submarine status, finish off the rest of Putin's helicopters, and it's gonna be a shame if anything happened to half the power plants in Russia...

Haha, and I'd trade every one of those guilty pleasures just to know that some Russian scientist somewhere was secretly refilling spent tritium reservoirs with sugar water...

Also the ISS dodged more space junk this week: (from the Russian ASAT "test" last Nov.)

ISS had to avoid Space Junk... Again | Sabine Hossenfelder (Nov 2, 2022)

 
IMHO it's time for Ukraine to finish off that bridge Putin was so proud of, promote the rest of Russia's boats to Submarine status, finish off the rest of Putin's helicopters, and it's gonna be a shame if anything happened to half the power plants in Russia...

The Ukrainians are doing the best they can. Putin's helicopters are not a huge factor in this war.

I hope the US is secretly rehabbing a lot of equipment that was in storage. Abrahms require a long logistical trail the Ukrainians may not be able to support and F-16s will take training for both pilots and ground crews, but there are a lot of IFVs and APCs in storage and the Ukrainians could make use of those right now. They already have made heavy use of the Hummers they have gotten, which they are using as APCs. For the winter they need tracked vehicles though.
 
I think the point is if Ukraine and all the other former eastern block countries switch to the standard European gauge it would be one more thing to deter Russia from invading since they are so reliant on rail transport.
Well there is quite big amount of cargo from Russia/Belarus to Latvian and Lithuanian ports. And there is obligation for transit via Lithuania to Prussia (aka kaliningrad).
 
  • Like
Reactions: UltradoomY
1667565218750.png


Another day with very heavy losses for Russia. I think Ukraine are following this advice:
1667565287432.png

They are happy keeping current lines, using their superior artillery to pick off poorly equipped Russian. And when given the chance they will move forward, but no stress while Russian is losing so many troops.

Video about the crimes in Bucha:
 
Last edited:
View attachment 870984

Another day with very heavy losses for Russia. I think Ukraine are following this advice:
View attachment 870985
They are happy keeping current lines, using their superior artillery to pick off poorly equipped Russian. And when given the chance they will move forward, but no stress while Russian is losing so many troops.

It also reminds me of Patton's quote:
“No dumb bastard ever won a war by going out and dying for his country. He won it by making some other dumb bastard die for his country.”

Either way it's playing out on the battlefield, one or both of the quotes are being exercised by Ukraine.

Something big is definitely going on. Ukrainian put out a call for media silence and the OINT guys are keeping mum if they are getting any indication what's going on. We do know the Ukrainians are putting pressure on around Svatove and Kherson. From reading wartranslated Russians are complaining about how accurate Ukrainian artillery is and the newly mobilized troops are taking casualties from artillery, but I doubt that accounts for all the losses the last week.

I'm a bit befuddled by people who are talking about how Russia is going to end this war like the end of the Korean War with a stalemate. The Russian army is in the process of a Lanchester Square Collapse.

The troops are getting restless (like they did in 1917), they are running out of basic equipment, and probably running short of some munitions. Newly mobilized troops are headed to the front are getting rusted out rifles and no other equipment. Not even hand grenades, MANPADS, infantry AT weapons, or anything else. The helmets they are being issued look like they are made of aluminum.

The mobilization has been a disaster. Stories abound of about 200,000 of the mobilized troops are being housed in horrible conditions in Russia and they just sit around because there are no instructors to train them, no equipment for them to train with, and not even basics like sleeping bags. Many intercepted phone calls from people in Ukraine talk about all the officers have either been killed or ran away. Groups of newly mobilized men are sent somewhere and told to hold a position with no leadership and no experienced people who even know how to dig a foxhole. The men complain of only getting fed every 2-3 days with one ration pack per two people. The ration packs are supposed to be one meal for one man. They also get no water so people are drinking from puddles. Some complain that everyone in their unit is sick with something.

The newly mobilized were promised 300,000 rubles, but nobody has seen that. Some are getting 3000-4000 a month (about $40 USD), but they are forced to pay for their food. The ones paid on the frontline are paid with debit cards instead of cash and there are no machines around that take the cards.

Some men who were supposed to be rotated home have been pulled back to the border region and are not allowed to leave.

T-62s that are 60 years old are replacing T-72s, T-80s, and T-90s on the front lines.

Some ancient artillery pieces are being seen too. A video of an artillery piece from WW II era with a wobbly tire under tow was out there a couple of weeks ago. Some other guns made in the 40s or 50s have been seen. The Ukrainians have captured some of them.

The Russian army is in bad shape and getting worse daily. It can't be rebuilt into any effective without pulling units out of combat and going through extensive re-equipment and training combined with manufacturing of enough new equipment for all the mauled units. Something that would take 6 months minimum under optimal conditions, but would take years from where Russia is today. Their army will continue to disintegrate until they leave Ukraine (as long as the west doesn't cut support, which is unlikely).

The Russian army is not an army that's going to be able to hold any land for very long against a determined and well equipped foe who wants it back. Ukraine is moving slowly right now, probably because they are trying to limit casualties (letting artillery attrit the Russians at low cost) and the weather is muddy right now in a lot of places that makes maneuver more difficult.
 
Lots of indications seem to point to Russia exiting Kherson west (right) bank and blowing lots up behind, possibly including destroying the hydro eqpt at the dam




I was going to post a couple of days ago that it's looking more like some sort of trap than a retreat. I'm seeing more and more commentary putting that theory forward. I suspect UKR are a few steps ahead already and won't fall for any poorly laid plans.
I really hope so.
 
If you want to understand why Putin invaded Ukraine in 2022 then this (3 hour and 20 minute video) is a must watch.


Fridman asked if Putin was good or bad for Russia. Hill replied that up until the 2016 annexation of Crimea, Putin was good for Russia because he was focused on building the economy. But after the annexation he was more focused on building an empire (or something like that).

There is a lot about American politics that will probably be hard for people to watch regardless of their political persuasion because foibles of both sides are exposed. That does not mean this is the gospel truth but I hope most can agree it's good to get a fresh perspective and to try to understand the other side.
 
I would not be sanguine about the Russian army folding. They still have enormous capacity for terror, they artful in mining and artillery, willing to see 300k to grave to appease imperial aspirations. Terrible combination

If you read wartranslated a number of phone calls people tell family back home that the Ukrainian artillery is incredibly accurate and deadly and the Russian artillery couldn't hit anything. Many who know artillery have been saying the barrels of Russian artillery is wearing out. Before the barrel fails completely the accuracy goes to hell because the barrel warps. As the war has evolved the Russians have gone from almost all self propelled artillery to a high number of towed guns, probably because the SP guns are either broken down or destroyed.

The tempo of Russian artillery has also dropped off quite a bit in the last few months. This could either be from lack of crews, lack of guns, or lack of ammunition, or any combination. Considering their dire situation I strongly doubt they are holding back for any strategic or tactical reason. During the summer the artillery was the only arm of their forces that was effective in any way.

They are pulling out all the stops to attack Ukrainian cities as much as possible, but that is becoming less effective as the Ukrainians get better defenses. Russia is also running low on their domestic stock of precision missiles. They have been using S-300 anti-air missiles in the ground attack role, which is a major waste of resources. There has been a lot of talk about Russia getting Iranian ballistic missiles, but estimates of Iran's stockpile of these weapons are that they don't have that many of them and the production rate is low. Estimates are that the Iranians have made less than 100 launchers.

Iran does appear to have lots of the kamikaze drones, but the Ukrainians are getting better at shooting them down.

It's basically V-1 and V-2s all over again. They did damage to London and were feared by the population for good reason, but they did nothing to soften British support for the war. Same thing is happening now. All the attacks are doing is deepening the hatred Ukrainians have for Russians.

Among the equipment the Ukrainians are getting are state of the art mine detection and removal equipment. Mines are a nuisance and unfortunately they can cause civilian casualties many years after a war (SE Asia is still dealing with mines the US sowed in the Vietnam War), but for a modern army that is careful and has the right equipment, they are a nuisance weapon. They maim and kill some troops, but not significant numbers.

Russia can keep their army in the field for now, but the losses are like a cancer eating away at the entire organization. Complaints from troops is normal in every army. There is a certain level of background complaints that are normal. There are two signs to watch for as a commander. If the troops quit complaining, it's a sign that morale is poor and fighting effectiveness is down. Drug use may be becoming a problem. That happened to the US forces in Vietnam to some degree.

The other is if the complaints go from nuisance mistakes such as about the quality of the food or about some obnoxious squad members to more fundamental problems like the troops don't have adequate shelter or any food at all. You aren't at risk of mutiny if people are complaining that the food is bad, but you are at risk if people are complaining that there is no food. People who feel there is nothing to lose are a lot more dangerous than people who do have something to lose. If the choice is between starving to death, freezing to death, or overthrowing the commanders and risking being shot people are much more willing to risk being shot.

Large scale rebellion in the army is usually an end of war scenario for any army. Some of the bigger cases have led to major changes in governments too.
 
If you read wartranslated a number of phone calls people tell family back home that the Ukrainian artillery is incredibly accurate and deadly and the Russian artillery couldn't hit anything. Many who know artillery have been saying the barrels of Russian artillery is wearing out. Before the barrel fails completely the accuracy goes to hell because the barrel warps. As the war has evolved the Russians have gone from almost all self propelled artillery to a high number of towed guns, probably because the SP guns are either broken down or destroyed.

The tempo of Russian artillery has also dropped off quite a bit in the last few months. This could either be from lack of crews, lack of guns, or lack of ammunition, or any combination. Considering their dire situation I strongly doubt they are holding back for any strategic or tactical reason. During the summer the artillery was the only arm of their forces that was effective in any way.

They are pulling out all the stops to attack Ukrainian cities as much as possible, but that is becoming less effective as the Ukrainians get better defenses. Russia is also running low on their domestic stock of precision missiles. They have been using S-300 anti-air missiles in the ground attack role, which is a major waste of resources. There has been a lot of talk about Russia getting Iranian ballistic missiles, but estimates of Iran's stockpile of these weapons are that they don't have that many of them and the production rate is low. Estimates are that the Iranians have made less than 100 launchers.

Iran does appear to have lots of the kamikaze drones, but the Ukrainians are getting better at shooting them down.

It's basically V-1 and V-2s all over again. They did damage to London and were feared by the population for good reason, but they did nothing to soften British support for the war. Same thing is happening now. All the attacks are doing is deepening the hatred Ukrainians have for Russians.

Among the equipment the Ukrainians are getting are state of the art mine detection and removal equipment. Mines are a nuisance and unfortunately they can cause civilian casualties many years after a war (SE Asia is still dealing with mines the US sowed in the Vietnam War), but for a modern army that is careful and has the right equipment, they are a nuisance weapon. They maim and kill some troops, but not significant numbers.

Russia can keep their army in the field for now, but the losses are like a cancer eating away at the entire organization. Complaints from troops is normal in every army. There is a certain level of background complaints that are normal. There are two signs to watch for as a commander. If the troops quit complaining, it's a sign that morale is poor and fighting effectiveness is down. Drug use may be becoming a problem. That happened to the US forces in Vietnam to some degree.

The other is if the complaints go from nuisance mistakes such as about the quality of the food or about some obnoxious squad members to more fundamental problems like the troops don't have adequate shelter or any food at all. You aren't at risk of mutiny if people are complaining that the food is bad, but you are at risk if people are complaining that there is no food. People who feel there is nothing to lose are a lot more dangerous than people who do have something to lose. If the choice is between starving to death, freezing to death, or overthrowing the commanders and risking being shot people are much more willing to risk being shot.

Large scale rebellion in the army is usually an end of war scenario for any army. Some of the bigger cases have led to major changes in governments too.
Didn't you say Russia would be out of ammunition in March / April? Get off this the sky is falling schtick. The way you guys are eating up Ukrainian propaganda is hilarious considering how quickly you call ANY report / statement from Russia "deceiving".

You have been preaching the end of Russia "is imminent" for almost 1 year now. I think it is time to hang up being an international strategic warfare advisor and admit you're throwing sht at the wall and hoping it sticks.
 
Didn't you say Russia would be out of ammunition in March / April? Get off this the sky is falling schtick. The way you guys are eating up Ukrainian propaganda is hilarious considering how quickly you call ANY report / statement from Russia "deceiving".

You have been preaching the end of Russia "is imminent" for almost 1 year now. I think it is time to hang up being an international strategic warfare advisor and admit you're throwing sht at the wall and hoping it sticks.
Oh boy, now you done it.