I noticed the Stance spare shows size 155/85R18, while the other 2 show 145/85/18. Does that matter?
So then it looks like the Stance is a wider thread tire, which means it's heavier and takes up more space. Unless you're going to carry a full size tire as a spare, most spares now are compact and designed to get you someplace close to get your tire repaired to buy a new tire.
When I bought my new 2023 Model Y Performance I replaced the heavy 21" UberTurbine wheels with a TSportline 18" TS5 wheel set and couldn't be happier. My car gets Model Y LR range, is quicker, has a better ride and beefier side walls that stick out farther than the rims, to protect against curb rash. Plus, since they are all the same size I can do a proper cross pattern tire rotation. I do want a spare tire for trips and had been thinking maybe I want a TSportline full size wheel as the spare with the pressure sensor but it's $680 after 15% off and free shipping, and takes up too much storage space. As of today I'm starting to lean towards the TSportline TS1 spare tire, with the 15% off and free shipping it's around $331 for the wheel with tote bag and $399 for the wheel, tote bag and tool kit, I'd want the tool kit.
The StanceMagic spare is $355 for the wheel with tool kit on Amazon with free shipping. The Modern Spare is $490 for the wheel with tote bag and tool kit, but shipping isn't free and another $48 to my area. I think the TSportline spare is the best deal for me right now. But I really wish the next generation of airless tires was on the market because it's ridiculous that we need a spare tire due to flats and more car companies are not including spare tires and they're not designing a place for then in the cars. So for us, it's an extra cost for something that is difficult to safely store in the car and take up space.
One thing to note, I have always carried a tire plug kit, small air compressor in my vehicles. A spare tire would be better when it's rainy or dark and cold outside or I'm wearing dress clothes. Put the spare on to get someplace safe, dry and warm, then plug the tire (if it's pluggable), continue the drive until the tire can be replaced.
I better go place my order before I talk myself out of it. lol
