Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

TSLA Market Action: 2018 Investor Roundtable

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
Status
Not open for further replies.
They took last week off, and today is... Tuesday.

Not sure how quickly you are expecting stats?

That's my point. Your earlier post seemed to assume they were up and running at a high sustained rate. I just wanted to point out that we have no idea of how well they're doing.

If I misunderstood you, my apologies mate!
 
Last edited:
TT007, I love your enthusiasm for TSLA. I love how your predictions always make me feel, for a brief time, like I'm going to be a multi-millionaire within a week or two.

But having said that, I will only tolerate your ambitious posts if you agree to start using a period every once in awhile. Please. My eyes need a brief pause occasionally so they can breathe. Like. This.

Thank you. :)
View attachment 315842
Periods, and that disclaimer of his, I forget how it goes exactly, something like "I really don't know what I'm talking about and I don't care if I'm right or wrong and not an advice".
 
  • Funny
Reactions: skitown
You are missing the context!
The post you replied to was in reply to the bird's question which itself was based on a false premise: why was tesla not able to ever produce a profitable quarter ? Hint: they had 2 profitable quarters: one in 2013, another in 2016.

So the same pattern was applied in the response question -- asking a 'why' on a totally unsubstantiated statement.

Thank you, @ZsoZso, for understanding & explaining my point.

I would like to add that my question was actually less baseless than @FirebirdAlpha ’s question. While there is no available information that Chanos has covered, there’s no available information that he hasn’t— so my question was (intentionally) baseless but possibly true. There is readily available information that Tesla has had profitable quarters— so FirebirdAlpha’s question was not only baseless, but clearly false.
 
Who sounds like a bear? Seriously, I'm pretty sure you're not a bear but many people think that model 3 will be a hit in Europe (myself included).

I think Model 3 will be a hit in Europe but a lesser hit than in the US. Like the Gen II cars.

The differences in price of energy is not going to make Model 3 a bigger hit in Europe relative to the US. That was my contention.

In the real world I am a hyper bull. In this forum I am an ultra cautious bull with only 30% of my net worth in TSLA.

Some senior posters here were stating that by the time Tesla delivered the first Model 3 there would be millions of Model 3 reservations, demand for ICEv would dry up and several legacy OEMs would be declaring bankruptcy. The ultra uber extreme bullishness needs to be tempered with reality.

I am proponent of the US trading with first world countries plus the BRIC countries on equal terms. The time we accepted unfair trade, where our allies placed higher tariff and non-tariff barriers on the USA than we placed on them should be over. We did that after WWII because the European,Japanese, and Korean economies were destroyed and ours was not. I do not object to giving the extremely poor countries favorable trade terms. But the time we accept 10%-25% tariffs on our goods and charge 2.5% on their goods should be over.

Even a two front trade war doesn't with China and Europe doesn't greatly affect the US economy. And we have settled terms with the South Koreans.

BTW My objection to "you sound like a TSLA bear" in taking my projections and turning them into "promises". Like TSLA bears make promises out of every Elon speculation.
 
You seem to be objecting to more points than I was attempting to make. I think the Model 3 will do well on both continents. Perhaps the Europeans will appreciate the higher power that the Model 3 will deliver. That can be just as compelling as saving money on fuel.

You seem to be making points in a theoretical vacuum that make perfect sense in that vacuum.

But the larger real world realities compromises those conclusions.
 
I feel you're missing the context. In USA no one really, really thinks about price of the gas. Yeah, it's a something one notices at the pump, occasionally is subject of conversation, but it's not real consideration. Not like in Europe.
In Europe, it's a real consideration in a way that it drives decision (of everyone) which engine to get (small and/or diesel), and that people will consider driving/no driving as a genuine choice for many a trip (even when they have a car).
Gold standard in operating car inexpensively was diesel, to the point that German sport sedans were being sold (and bought) with asthmatic 1.6l diesel engines. Many of my friends (until couple of years back) would have never considered anything but diesel.

And electric is still more economical than diesel. That's all that buyer will care about. Is there a cheaper way to drive? Nope. They'll calculate that it costs them equivalent of 3-3.8l per 100km on electric, even less with M3, with diesel 5-7l, small gas car 7-10l, and Tesla MS sized car 10-15l, and they'll be happy. Funny thing is, I feel(I'm not sure, but anecdotally) European buyers will overpay for future savings. Diesel engined cars always (used to?) sell at the premium to slightly more powerful gas engine.

Again, this mindset does not present itself in the same way in NA*. I've lived it, and my brother still does, so I get it.

*Decades of cheap gas have conditioned us one way, and decades of even more expensive gas have conditioned Europeans another way. Gas price gap used to be even wider in the past.

There is a gas tax revolt going on in California. Not Kentucky or Texas but California. Over $.12 per gallon. There is a massive ballot box initiative that has a 50/50 chance of passing and where Republicans are outnumbered by over 2-1 the Republican candidate for governor has a real chance of winning. All over a 12 cents per gallon tax hike.

Don't tell me Americans don't think about the price of gas.

I keep hearing about all the uber rational Norther Europeans that strongly look at TCO when buying a car. Now they are going to overpay for future fuel savings on Model 3? Even if it doesn't pan out on the number crunching relative to typical small engined hatchback?
 
That's my point. Your earlier post seemed to assume they were up and running at a high sustained rate. I just wanted to point out that we have no idea of how well they're doing.

If I misunderstood you, my apologies mate!

What about my post made you think it wasn't present tense and in-progress and therefore not complete?

When I talked about being >5K and aiming for 10K in 6+ months from now, did you think that if we didn't have hard evidence of such 48 hours after a week-lmh sjut down they had given up on ramping to greater than 5K?

And as for "assuming", Elon states they already were aiming for 6K "next month"...

I'm not quite sure what your contention is?
 
What about my post made you think it wasn't present tense and in-progress and therefore not complete?

When I talked about being >5K and aiming for 10K in 6+ months from now, did you think that if we didn't have hard evidence of such 48 hours after a week-lmh sjut down they had given up on ramping to greater than 5K?

And as for "assuming", Elon states they already were aiming for 6K "next month"...

I'm not quite sure what your contention is?

Dude, I don't want to argue with you, wasn't my intention at all. Just stating unless we've got inside information, we really don't know where the M3 lines are for sustained production rates. While I am a huge Elon fan, I'll believe 6K weekly sustained production when I get confirmation. I hope and believe they can do it by the end of the 3rd quarter, but I'm not going to assume it until they do it.

But no worries mate, I'm just saying let's not take it as a given... stuff can happen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kbM3
Dude, I don't want to argue with you, wasn't my intention at all. Just stating unless we've got inside information, we really don't know where the M3 lines are for sustained production rates. While I am a huge Elon fan, I'll believe 6K weekly sustained production when I get confirmation. I hope and believe they can do it by the end of the 3rd quarter, but I'm not going to assume it until they do it.

But no worries mate, I'm just saying let's not take it as a given... stuff can happen.
Not arguing... but my post was in the context of 6 months+ out. Seriously, what conclusions are you attempting to draw after one day back from shutdown?
 
The short burn in three weeks could be happening in a way that was unexpected - any surprise for Musk?
InsideEvs is reporting a 455 mile range for the AWD and performance 3.
This would be a huuuuuge deal.
If true, I think the stock pops.

Tesla Model 3 AWD & Performance Rated With 455-Mile Range By CARB


(to spare those just reading this the need to disagree or comment, this is not real miles. I got sucked in. )
 
Last edited:
I'm not drawing any bloody conclusions!!!! That's my point. Go argue with yourself.
OK.

The context of my post was that they weren't going to be only at 5K a week as they work through the backlog, and that they'd ramp to above that point sometime by the time we got in 2019.

But you are right. That's an assumption... based on Elon's target of 6K in a month, but I absolutely have no proof. They very well could never manage 5K again, much less ever get to the 10K they have publicly targeted.

So, now that we are a whopping 24 hours past the week-long shutdown, it's silly to even assume that we will see better than 5K over the course of time they will need to work through a 400K+ backlog... even though... you know... they went from 0 to 5K in a little over six months.

Ridiculous of me to even assume that might happen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: neroden and landis
OK.

The context of my post was that they weren't going to be only at 5K a week as they work through the backlog, and that they'd ramp to above that point sometime by the time we got in 2019.

But you are right. That's an assumption... based on Elon's target of 6K in a month, but I absolutely have no proof. They very well could never manage 5K again, much less ever get to the 10K they have publicly targeted.

So, now that we are a whopping 24 hours past the week-long shutdown, it's silly to even assume that we will see better than 5K over the course of time they will need to work through a 400K+ backlog... even though... you know... they went from 0 to 5K in a little over six months.

Ridiculous of me to even assume that might happen.

Well mate, we can hope! I have confidence they'll get to at least 7,500 a week by year end. Wish we had something better than that Bloomberg tool to depend on, but we'll hear more about it in about a month at the quarterly report.

Go Tesla!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.