@Struja I recently bought some of those center cap stickers for my 3rd party wheels, they do look good and seem to be of good, durable quality. Got mine, grey with white Tesla logo, from:
3dcarstickers.com
the website doesn't list Tesla ones but he can make them for you them if you email a request.
If you need I can post a photo of mine, just ask
ps I had no problems using a 3rd party tire shop for extra set of wheels and tires. On my new summer wheels (with OEM Michelins) they put 3rd party programmable TPMS sensors which work fine with the car, and they also cloned them with the original sensors so I don't need to reset the sensors in the car when swapping wheels. Like others have recommended, I too have Hakka R2 tires (on my original 19" wheels) and I find them to be a great winter tire, not noisy to my ears. We do have WRG3-SUV tires year-round on our CR-V which I do also like but hard to compare directly, as the ICE is noisy to begin with, plus tread pattern on the -SUV variant is different from the WRG3 version you'd get in size suitable for the Model S.