I was there last night. 1A and 1B are taped off with a Tesla sign saying they're out of order. I plugged in to 2A and it latched and the port went blue, but no charging. My dash said something about waiting for charging to commence. I moved to 4A and it worked fine.
As to why, your guess is as good as mine, however I suspect one or more of the charger modules inside the gated enclosure has gone bad.
- - - Updated - - -
Here's something weird. I noticed on the ConnecTT app, it is showing a Supercharger station in downtown Waterloo. In the screen capture below, the red symbol is for Superchargers and the grey ones are for Destination Chargers. I'm assuming this is a mistake, but the fact that it is shown and named as "Kitchener-Waterloo" in the app makes me wonder just what it is. If you tap the button, it even opens up the typical screen allowing you to Check In, add photos and such. There is nothing shown on PlugShare (of any type) for several blocks around this area. It wouldn't really be a good location for a Supercharger anyway, but I wonder where this information came from?
View attachment 89438