Hi Velo1! First of all, you look gorgeous in the sun!
Second, thanks for the pictures! You inspired me to visit my local Mercedes-Benz dealership today. They have a color called Lunar Blue that I think is probably somewhat close to the Tesla blue -- very dark, very rich metallic blue. Looks really luscious. They also had several used cars (2008) in a similar dark blue, and in white. So, it was a nice opportunity to see how the colors hold up with age.
My current thinking:
- White was always my plan, and I still like the car in white.
- White absolutely hides dirt and small imperfections. It is easier to maintain.
- On the other hand, white tends to accentuate any small imperfections in panel fit, and the trunk gap stands out pretty powerfully on a white car.
- The blue tends to hide panel fit issues
- The metal flake in the blue hides a little bit of dust, compared to a straight black
- But, the blue gets hot in the sun! Holy cow. The dealer had two E350s parked right next to each other, with the sun hitting them at the same angle. One in white, one in Lunar Blue. The blue car was literally too hot to touch. I could not hold my hand against it. The white car was slightly warm.
- The paint around the door handles on the 2008 used blue car looked terrible. Wow. It didn't look too fabulous on the white either, to be honest. Localized paint armor just at that spot would have made those cars far more appealing. The Tesla shouldn't have such an issue, thanks to the handle design. A little paint armor on the body colored piece that slides out with the handle is probably not a bad idea, though.
- The 2008 blue car looked quite good, considering. The air dam had been scraped against something white, which stood out like crazy, but I don't count that as a fault of the paint. The driver should have scraped something painted a darker color! There were some fine scratches in the paint that I suspect a good detailer could eliminate. But, washed and with a coat of wax on it, it looked nice. It was every bit as screaming hot as the 2012 in the sun, though.
- The 2008 white car had extensive swirl marks in the finish. From most angles, it was invisible. If you got the sun at the right (wrong?) angle, you could see them. On a darker color, I think it would have been intolerable.
- I've noticed in some TMC member photos and some of my own photos that Tesla's clear tail lights look.... a bit odd with certain colors. I think they look a bit peculiar on the Dolphin Grey, and they look a bit dark on the white cars. I sincerely wish that Tesla had used red lenses like Audi and Mercedes use, and like their original prototype used. Interestingly, the clear lenses look great, IMO, on the blue car, the black car, and both reds.
- IMO, the chrome accents on the Model S (around the windows, across the rear, and under the doors) look better with either a very dark color (including black), or a color that is not on the grey/white spectrum (including Sunset Red). I think they tend to blend in a bit too much on the silver and grey cars especially, but also a bit on the white. On those colors, the chrome strip below the door reads as part of the doors, which makes them look odd, whereas on the other colors, it's clearly an accent.
In short, I think the blue Model S is a very fine choice if you are willing to put in the extra maintenance of a darker car. I am really torn between it and white. I posted in another thread that I had ruled the blue out after my visit to the local Audi dealer, where their dark metallic blue looked pretty bad with a little dirt and water spotting on it, but I am drawn to it nonetheless.
Velo1, regarding the choice you and your wife will make between the blue and the black, I'll offer my own opinion, which you can take for whatever you think it's worth: Get the blue. If the black were a pearl black like Mercedes offers, I think that'd be fine, but next to the conventional black on the Tesla, the blue is a far more elegant look. As well, out of the sun, the car effectively looks black anyway, so you get the best of both worlds.
I've attached two photos I took at Palo Alto, showing the blue car and the black car from the same angle in the same light. I'm sorry it's only from one angle, but I hope they give you a good comparison. (Click to enlarge)
View attachment 8130
View attachment 8131