I did quote them but they were quite a bit higher for me (not even close to as bad as Geico though). I’m a younger guy so that may be part of it. I’ve got full coverage (similar to yours but with a few less options like no rental coverage) on the Tesla and my old Chevy truck at around $125 a month through progressive.I've been with State Farm for years and the policy on my Audi S4 was about $100/mo. I shopped around quite a bit and other companies had higher rates with a lot less coverage and much higher deductibles. I've been driving for about 20 years with a clean record, and my premium increased by about $20/mo for the same coverage. I would definitely get a quote from them as they seem to be one of the better ones for Tesla.
Bodily Injury Coverage
Limit Per Accident $300,000
Limit Per Person $100,000
Property Damage Coverage
Limit Per Accident $100,000
Comprehensive Coverage
Deductible $250
Collision Coverage
Deductible $250
Uninsured/Underinsured Motor Vehicle Coverage
Limit Per Person $100,000
Limit Per Accident $300,000
Personal Injury Protection Coverage
Aggregate Limit $10,000
Car Rental/Travel Expenses Coverage
Limit Per Occurrence $1,200
Limit Per Day $50
State Farm was the first other company I thought to quote since my parents use them and are very happy with their experience.