I was going to take the day off after all the craziness but will share some ramblings on my current thoughts on price movements.
First though, I thought the series of Elon Musk interview segments by CNBC this morning were helpful:
Musk: - CNBC
Elon Musk on Teslas stock price - CNBC
Teslas CEO on crash results - CNBC
Three things that could slow down Tesla
From the videos, the one that stuck out the most was about lithium ion cell production and the need for a "giga" factory of huge proportion. Also, that Elon/Tesla is considering building (or helping to build) that factory. This is good news to me because as a long-term investor (for my core holding) I don't want Elon to underestimate Model E (Gen III) demand several years out (see my thoughts here,
Short-Term TSLA Price Movements - Page 616).
It's also interesting from the videos, that Elon views volatility as part of TSLA's price movements due to varying opinions on Model E (Gen III) execution. This reminds me of the article I referred to a few weeks ago regarding that one of the main factors of volatility is the dispersion of beliefs (ie., wide ranging opinions on a company that allow two camps to form - an extreme exuberant camp, and an extreme naysayer camp). As TSLA stock rises because the believers believe even more in Model E (Gen III) over time, the high stock price can also empower naysayers saying that the valuation is ridiculous and that they have no chance against the big auto makers. The volatility is going to be interesting and that's the main reason for me spending a lot of time thinking and dialoguing about it.
Alright, so on to today's price movements. Yesterday I wrote that once we break 151 or so we could see a rapid rise as buyers start to chase the stock and traders fuel the momentum. After it broke 151 this morning, I told my wife that the ideal situation for our current short-term play (Sep13 150s) would be for TSLA to touch 155 today and settle down in the 152-154 range. Then, slowly inch up over the next few to several days until it takes out the $158.88 ATH that will push it to the 160s (and maybe touching 170 or more). However, I told her that if things rise really fast in the 150s and try to take out the ATH quickly, then it becomes less predictable because the movements are so volatile, meaning while it skyrockets up, it could come tanking down fast as well.
Anyway, after the Nasdaq freeze ended we got a surprising run to $157. Now from here probably the most likely scenario is that it tests $158 (or close to $158.88) and fails because there are too many profit-takers. If the stock is really strong, then it will keep trying to push the ATH and eventually break through and then we're off to the 160s and running. But it tries to break through the $158.88 ATH but doesn't break through and the stock isn't strong, then we could see the stock retreat and start consolidating in the 150s. I see $152 as a sort of resistance level on the downside. However, if there is a market scare (ie., deeper correction) and TSLA is affected, then it could break down the $152 level and then we could be looking at the 140s again. I don't see this scenario as highly likely in the next few days (of course things could change) but I feel like it's wise to consider the various possibilities.
So, mostly I think the two main scenarios are that TSLA tests the ATH (either tomorrow or in the coming days), fails and consolidates in the 150s. Of if the stock is really strong, then it tests the ATH $158.88, breaks through and we're in the 160s.
Now, the question is what would make the stock strong enough to break through the ATH of $158.88 as early as tomorrow? Basically, I think it comes down to buyer's attitudes. If there are buyers who think that TSLA in the 150s is cheap and this might be their only chance, and there are enough of these buyers, then the stock can be strong enough to break through the ATH as early as tomorrow. However, what makes it complicated is that we don't know all the buyers out there. For example, we might have a decent pulse on the attitude of the retail buyer (but then maybe not), but we don't know what funds/institutions are doing. Also, sometimes it can take just one or two major buyers on a buying spree to provide good rising rice support and traders will pick up on that and will fuel it with momentum. Also, on the flip side there could be some major sellers (that we don't know about) that provide downward selling pressure on the stock.
That's why it's tough to say with confidence what will happen tomorrow (or any day). We just don't know the entire buyer/seller situation. But if I had to guess odds, I'd probably guess 65-75% we don't break through the ATH of $158.88 tomorrow. 20-30% we do break through the ATH on surprisingly solid strength. The reason why I give 20-30% (which is kind of generous) is because TSLA surprised us today with strength and it shows that there could be strength tomorrow that surprises us as well (ie., hidden big buyers). But, logically when you look at the chart and the huge spike today from $148 to $157, you think that it's should consolidate tomorrow (thus the 65-75% odds). Then, there's always the chance the market tanks 1-2% and takes down TSLA into the 140s (I'd give that a 2-7% chance).
Regarding my recent trade (Sep13 150s), when TSLA successfully broke through $150.5 it changed radically changed my trade's equation because now it is "safely" (relatively) in the 150s. Thus, I'm thinking of putting a stop loss order in for $149-149.50 since if it reaches that point, then the stock will be behaving significantly different than how I'm expecting it to (ie., consolidate in 150s and break through ATH). So, at that point I'll take the loss from now (ie., stock at $157) but still exit the trade with a decent profit. If I didn't think TSLA could break through that ATH within the next week or two (and if I didn't have such a large margin of safety in my trade because the options were purchased when the stock was at $138), then I'd probably take profits soon. Also, part of my thesis on this trade was that it could quickly recover from the 130s and break through the $158.88 ATH onto 160s (and possible 170). Thus, I'd like to see my trade through even if it costs me some short-term paper loss (ie., the stock goes down to $152 tomorrow). But this is a high-risk approach, because it'd be much safer to take some profit now and maybe leave some to ride or even try to repurchase at a lower price. But with decent gains so far, I can use that as a cushion of sorts to absorb some higher risk than what I'd normally be comfortable with.
On a side note, it was just two weeks ago Tesla reported Q2 ER and we reached the ATH of $158.88 (closing at $153.48). Then, things tanked (eventually touching $135). And now we're back at $157 and in arms reach of a new ATH. What a roller coaster of a ride.