Roadster #244, 5 years old now, 18K miles.
Very minor issues:
1. Cracked sill cover (replaced under warranty)
2. Passenger headrest pad fell off (glued it back on)
3. Console knobs cracked (replaced under warranty)
4. Trim ring around front speaker cracked (replaced under warranty)
5. Starting to get a little squeaky.
6. Plastic pads on the soft top pins breaking/wearing off. I didn't even notice. Tesla replaced the top during annual service.
7. Cut in seat from seat belt buckle. This was the most disturbing. It appears that there wax insufficient padding between the leather upholstery and the seat frame. This was repaired by a local upholstery shop at Tesla's expense (under warranty).
Overall, very satisfied.