Over time they’ll eat into the shine of the wheels. I’d just put the elbow grease in and they’ll look like newThe idea of nasty wheel cleaners is that you dont have to wipe the wheels and get into all the small gaps. Its spray on hose off. Nothing else required
As I said, grab wheel wax if you want an easy clean. I used it on previous euro cars I’ve owned which suffer from terrible brake dust. Wipes Straight off!