Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Russia/Ukraine conflict

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
I see a bilateral trade agreement shaping up: The USA exports trumpers and takes the Russian professional class.

Politics aside, indeed a large part of the U.S. engine/success story has been its ability to recruit skilled labor/professionals/intellectuals for most of its history. Their following generation as well is often similar. Much of this may have been structural/institutional benefits as opposed to frank policy, but excellent dividends none-the-less. A particular individual, one for whom without this forum would not exist, is one such example.


Article on the US Intelligence agencies helping target Russian generals
12 is the last count per Ukraine, though Russia so far has not fessed up to all at this point and a couple AFAIK not independently confirmed (yet?).
 
  • Like
Reactions: MC3OZ

Article on the US Intelligence agencies helping target Russian generals
That article is paywalled. I saw the same article in the NYT, which is also paywalled, but I have a subscription. The article title is a little too strong. Here is a snippet - bold is mine. No doubt our information has been very valuable, but the Ukranians fused it with their own.

U.S. Intelligence Is Helping Ukraine Kill Russian Generals, Officials Say

WASHINGTON — The United States has provided intelligence about Russian units that has allowed Ukrainians to target and kill many of the Russian generals who have died in action in the Ukraine war, according to senior American officials.

Ukrainian officials said they have killed approximately 12 generals on the front lines, a number that has astonished military analysts.

The targeting help is part of a classified effort by the Biden administration to provide real-time battlefield intelligence to Ukraine. That intelligence also includes anticipated Russian troop movements gleaned from recent American assessments of Moscow’s secret battle plan for the fighting in the Donbas region of eastern Ukraine, the officials said. Officials declined to specify how many generals had been killed as a result of U.S. assistance.
The United States has focused on providing the location and other details about the Russian military’s mobile headquarters, which relocate frequently. Ukrainian officials have combined that geographic information with their own intelligence — including intercepted communications that alert the Ukrainian military to the presence of senior Russian officers — to conduct artillery strikes and other attacks that have killed Russian officers.
 
Ukrainian officials have combined that geographic information with their own intelligence
Yes, Ukrainian intelligence is very good, many are still underestimating how much thought and preparation the Ukrainians have done.

I admit the Ukrainians have also surprised me in many ways, they are far more capable, intelligent, good humoured and resilient than I imagined. Mainly because prior to the war, I didn't know much about them.

It is slightly annoying that some in the western media and some politicians play down the achievements of the Ukrainians, undersell their capabilities, or try to tell them what sort of a deal they should accept.
 
Basically, the Russians will permanently occupy Ukrainian territory by an elaborate "ethnic cleansing" strategy. Women, children and the elderly fled the occupied eastern and southern Ukrainian lands. Others who didn't leave were rounded up and deported to Russia. The rest were either murdered or killed by bombing and missile attacks.

Remember how the Ukrainians stated that they would fight to the last man? If there's no last man, there can be no urban warfare against the Russian military. So now the war will fall back into its previous frontal stalemate. I don't see that the Ukrainian army has a strategic advantage in a frontal theater when the Russians can send missiles and bombs from Russia. The Ukrainians can't reciprocate except by staging hit and run attacks on Russian border targets. This is what Putin will announce on 9 May.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jbcarioca
Basically, the Russians will permanently occupy Ukrainian territory by an elaborate "ethnic cleansing" strategy. Women, children and the elderly fled the occupied eastern and southern Ukrainian lands. Others who didn't leave were rounded up and deported to Russia. The rest were either murdered or killed by bombing and missile attacks.

Remember how the Ukrainians stated that they would fight to the last man? If there's no last man, there can be no urban warfare against the Russian military. So now the war will fall back into its previous frontal stalemate. I don't see that the Ukrainian army has a strategic advantage in a frontal theater when the Russians can send missiles and bombs from Russia. The Ukrainians can't reciprocate except by staging hit and run attacks on Russian border targets. This is what Putin will announce on 9 May.
Ukraine is relying on the latest batch of weapons from overseas donors, plus some weapons they make themselves.

The aim is to destroy Russian equipment, mostly with Drones/Artillery but also with some handheld weapons, and Ukrainian developed missiles.

Ukraine can regain all of their territory, after that, they will be able to launch Done, Missile, Plane and Helicopter attacks over the border. But you are right, they need better defences against Russian Missiles and bombs.

According to the Ukrainians they do shoot down Russian planes, and fewer planes are venturing into Ukrainian airspace.

When Ukraine has regained all of their territory they can seek a peace deal, or they could seek it beforehand, that is up to them.

You are right about what Putin will announce, but my guess is Ukraine isn't ready to cede any territory, so the war will continue.

Specifically on the "frontal theatre" it is hoped that the artillery and tanks that have recently arrived will make a difference, and also Ukraine's local knowledge and ability to disrupt Russian supply lines. Drones of all types will make a difference. Ukraine seems to have a significant edge in Drones,
We need to see how this plays out, it will not be easy, but Ukraine now seems to have the equipment to at least attempt to do it.
 
Last edited:
50,000,000 times greater if my arithmetic and your units are correct.

Tera - E12
Mega - E6

Whoops, left off three zeros.

I see a bilateral trade agreement shaping up: The USA exports trumpers and takes the Russian professional class.

There are people in the US who have told reporters that they would rather have Putin as their president than Joe Biden or said that better Russian than Democrat. At minimum, send those people to Russia. Maybe some of them will get a clue that the people they idolize are much worse than the people they hate here.


Article on the US Intelligence agencies helping target Russian generals

The Russians are learning, but it's been painfully slow. They are being more cautious then they were in the first days of the war. However, if they do take anything away from this war, they should realize that if the Ukrainians can do as much as they can eliminating senior officers with their hodge podge of former Soviet equipment combined with some home grown and modern equipment from other countries, the US intelligence's ability to track their senior staff combined with US weapons would mean the US could wipe the board of most senior officers in a few days.

If I was a Russian officer, I would be terrified of NATO getting into this war.

Basically, the Russians will permanently occupy Ukrainian territory by an elaborate "ethnic cleansing" strategy. Women, children and the elderly fled the occupied eastern and southern Ukrainian lands. Others who didn't leave were rounded up and deported to Russia. The rest were either murdered or killed by bombing and missile attacks.

Remember how the Ukrainians stated that they would fight to the last man? If there's no last man, there can be no urban warfare against the Russian military. So now the war will fall back into its previous frontal stalemate. I don't see that the Ukrainian army has a strategic advantage in a frontal theater when the Russians can send missiles and bombs from Russia. The Ukrainians can't reciprocate except by staging hit and run attacks on Russian border targets. This is what Putin will announce on 9 May.

The Ukrainians are on the offensive now. They aren't talking about it much and the media isn't picking up on it. Most of what they are covering is the fighting around Kharkhiv.

Institute for the Study of War

The salient around Molodova is much wider than it was a couple of days ago. I thought they were pushing towards Kupoansk, but they widened the salient instead. They may still push through to Kupiansk in the coming days.

Kharkiv Battle Map Draft May 4,2022.png


Then in the south the gray area that ends near Nova Kakhova was blue a few days ago. It looks like they're are firming up their flanks around Novovorontsovka instead of pushing further south. These are areas the Ukrainians have advertised they are advancing. The gray salient may have grown, but neither side is talking about it.

Kherson and Mykolaiv Battle Map Draft May 4,2022.png


The Ukrainians defended Mariupol and a relatively small force tied down a much larger Russian force for two months. They also inflicted heavy casualties on the Russians. The Russians won a battle they should have won anyway, but it took 30X longer and had significant casualties. The definition of a Pyrrhic Victory.

Russia is running out of everything. Missile attacks are way down from a month ago. Most of their land based missile systems are silent because they are out of ammunition. Most of the missile strikes in recent weeks have been coming from the Black Sea. Their frigates and more recently their submarines have been firing missiles into Ukraine. Anti-shipping missile parts have been found around strikes indicating the Russians are so low on naval to land missiles that they are pressing anti-shipping missiles into the role. They have probably stripped their navy to do that.

Additionally their land based missile systems that didn't get committed to the war probably had their missiles stripped too.

Russia's ability to make more weapons has been compromised from the start. In the first weeks of the war their aircraft started dropping dumb bombs because they were out of smart bombs. They also lost the ability to make more smart bombs and missiles due to the sanctions. All their smart weapons require parts from Europe. Their tank factory also shut down in the early weeks of the war because of a lack of parts.

In the last few weeks they have been losing other military manufacturing. The chemical plant that burned to the ground near Moscow was the only plant in Russia that made some key chemicals needed to make gun ammunition and rocket fuel. The other day a munitions plant blew up and burned.

Rumor has it that on May 9 the Russians will formally declare war so they can fully mobilize the army. That sounds good on paper, but they are short of everything they need to do that: uniforms, boots, small arms, probably ammunition, etc. Even if they skip training all those raw recruits and send them directly into combat, it will take 2 months minimum before they get anybody on the front line. In the meantime the army they have is withering on the vine and the Ukrainians are starting on the offensive.

In two months time the Russians will be starting from square one (pushed back into Russia) with vastly poorer quality troops and a lot of equipment that's broken and needs to be rebuilt before they can be used. Their supply situation will be worse than it is now.

Russia is running out of the ability to make what weapons they can make without outside help due to sabotage. They also started the war with a bottleneck in their supply chain which was how many trucks they had in the army. They had vastly fewer than they should have had for an army their size. Those trucks have mostly been destroyed now. The ones that haven't have been beaten to death.

Trent Telenko was involved in rehabbing US trucks after two years of war in Iraq. US trucks are babied compared to Russian trucks and the US trucks had 20-30 years of wear on them after 2 years.

The Russians have a compromised ability to manufacture supply and they have an ever diminishing ability to deliver it. They are stripping Russia of civilian trucks to fill out their losses, which is destroying the trucks (civilian trucks aren't built to take the abuse they are getting) and it's leaving their economy with no trucks to move goods, including war goods.

All the sabotage attacks deep in Russia is an indication that they have a serious problem with an internal insurgency brewing from their own citizens. They are facing a possible rebellion or civil war. Conscription is already very, very unpopular in Russia. Draft riots are a thing many countries have faced. Russia could see a massive draft riot that ends up turning into some kind of significant, long lasting unrest and could break up the country.

This war is not going to settle into a war of attrition. Russia's army is going to start falling apart within the next month and Ukraine is getting stronger every day.
 
Now things are getting serious


Pope Francis has taken a pretty shameful position on the Ukraine invasion- laying the blame on NATO and Ukraine. I'm glad he's admonishing Kirill, but that doesn't come close to redeeming him for the awful things he has already said.
 
Excellent analysis, but few bones to pick though
There are people in the US who have told reporters that they would rather have Putin as their president than Joe Biden or said that better Russian than Democrat. At minimum, send those people to Russia. Maybe some of them will get a clue that the people they idolize are much worse than the people they hate here.
No argument, they deserve it, but while at it can we send the rabid pro-communist extreme left ones to Venezuela, North Korea or Cuba for a life changing experience too? All that horseshoe stuff about extremes...

Then in the south the gray area that ends near Nova Kakhova was blue a few days ago. It looks like they're are firming up their flanks around Novovorontsovka instead of pushing further south. These are areas the Ukrainians have advertised they are advancing. The gray salient may have grown, but neither side is talking about it.

Kherson and Mykolaiv Battle Map Draft May 4,2022.png
I'm afraid that grey salient is actually the Dnipro River. That's why is coded the same color as the Black Sea. The Ukrainian offensive around Novovorontsovka I think is about trying to cut the Russians from the Kakhovka Hydroelectric Power Plant Dam; it has a 2 lane road and railway bridge next of the dam. Securing it provides a direct route to Crimea.
1651760516089.png


The only other Dnipro River crossing to the south is east of Kherson, about 25 miles away from this dam, the Antonovskiy Bridge. And that's it all the way to the sea. I doubt that the Russian will retreat and leave it intact if they have to. Without either of the bridges there is no way to reach Crimea short of Zaporizhzhia, and that's 150 miles to the NE from Kakhovka. Losing both southern Dnipro crossings would make the logistics of liberating Crimea extremely difficult.
 
Last edited: