Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Waymo

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
Didn't she reach customer support? If so, it's hard to rig it.
How so? She hung up on the customer support lady who was telling her how to move the drop-off pin. That interaction is also edited. Her car door is open while acting all exasperated at the poor customer support lady, then it's suddenly closed when she says "I'm just going to confirm it and see what happens". With the pin in the same spot she (or her team) moved it to originally, she knows exactly what will happen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: diplomat33

I thought I would write a more detailed summary for people who maybe did not get a chance to watch the entire video:

Introduction
Waymo is only company in the world running a 24/7 commercial, fully autonomous ride-hailing service (since 2020)
10k+ rides/week (public riders, not including employees)
2M+ "rider-only" miles (no safety driver)
10M+ autonomous miles (with safety driver)
10B+ simulation miles
Tested in all weather conditions

Progress
24/7, fully autonomous (no safety driver) ride-hailing service in 47 sq mi in SF and 180 sq mi in metro Phoenix
Intent to scale 10x by next summer
Currently testing with no safety driver in LA. LA will be next fully autonomous ride-hailing service. LA ODD is "in between" SF and Phoenix so it will allow pretty rapid deployment.
Over past year, Waymo improved performance in adverse weather (rain, fog), improved capability to navigate construction areas including responding to temporary signs by construction workers, improved back-to-back lane changes in dense traffic.

Safety Data
Waymo published safety data on first 1M driverless miles. No injuries. 55% of incidents were from human drivers hitting a stationary Waymo. No incidents at intersections. No incidents with vulnerable road users (pedestrians etc). Only 2 collisions that meet NHTSA reporting. 18 minor contact events. 10% of all incidents happened at night.

Core Architecture & Long Tail
Waymo is making continuous improvements to core architecture and taking systematic approach to solving long tail. The better the core architecture, the smaller the "long tail" becomes. Waymo approach is built on foundation of data, evaluation, machine learning infrastructure and simulation.

Core Architecture
Waymo is focused on improving core architecture in two areas: motion prediction of many objects and lidar 3D object detection at long range.

Motion Prediction
Waymo developed improved multi-agent motion prediction using diffusion. NN takes in scene input (road, cars, pedestrians, traffic lights, etc) and generates lots of random possible paths of objects, It then puts that through a denoiser, which eliminates wrong paths and outputs clean single paths for all objects. Advantage that it does not require pre-defined "anchors".

Lidar 3D Object Detection at Long Range
Waymo lidar has 300m+ range. At longer ranges, lidar point cloud becomes sparser so object detection becomes more difficult. To address this problem, Waymo developed sparse window transformer NN that can do more efficient 3D object detection with fewer points.

Long Tail
To solve the long tail, Waymo is focused on two areas: identifying rare examples for training set and improving unsupervised perception and prediction.

Rare example mining
Objects can be easy or hard to detect (ie occluded object). Objects can also be common or rare. Objects difficult to detect are not necessarily rare. Identifying these rare examples allows you to add them to your training set which will help your autonomous driving better handle those edge cases. Waymo proposes model-centric and data-centric approach. Model-centric defines rare as uncertain objects minus difficult objects. Data-centric can estimate the rareness of an object based on the probability density of a data sample.

Results: using only 13% labeled data plus rare example mining, Waymo achieved 30.97% better detection of rare large vehicles than same 13% labeled data without rare example mining and only 5% worse than fully supervised training (100% labeled data).

Motion inspired unsupervised perception and prediction
The idea is to use unsupervised learning to auto-label new objects based on motion. You can then do object detection and prediction with these new auto-labels objects. This will allow your autonomous vehicle to handle new objects that it has not been trained on. Waymo has NN that takes raw lidar sequences and estimates motion and then auto labels objects. Waymo uses these auto labels to train their 3D object detector and trajectory predictor.

Example: A person with a stroller but only the person is labeled. The unsupervised 3D object detection auto-labels both the person and the stroller and predicts motion. Other examples: movers pushing a garbage bin or a person carrying a large box where you can only see their legs, the system correctly auto-labels objects.

Results: Fully supervised detector cannot generalize to new categories. Unsupervised auto labels on unknown categories improves generalization.

Conclusion
Achieving excellent product requires a holistic approach. It's not just about improving software but also hardware. For example: making sure hardware is self-cleaning, resistant to damage.

Example: Adverse weather can impact AV system in many different ways. Wet roads can create reflections that can confuse cameras, condensation like fog, mist and rain can alter sensor data, droplets, dirt or ice can foul surface of sensors, wet and icy road can be slippery, reducing friction.

Waymo can drive in "almost all fog" and "most rain conditions".

Current weather stations lack precision and specificity to help autonomous vehicles drive. Waymo leverages the sensors on each vehicle to turn each vehicle into a "mobile weather station". Waymo crowdsources millions of data points from the fleet to build a first of its kind real-time weather map to help their ride-hailing operations.

Waymo can automatically clean sensors when sensors detect dirt, condensation etc...

Waymo testing sensors to make sure they can withstand small impacts (for example: not uncommon at highway speeds to have bugs or small pebbles hit the sensors). Waymo needs to be able to continue to drive or be able to pull over when one or more sensors are degraded.

cc @Bladerskb I hope I accurately represented the info. The technical machine learning parts were a bit over my head. :)
 
Waymo says the bus was to blame for the "stall" incident last month:

"The incident occurred on June 19 at the corner of Clay and Leavenworth streets, reports KRON4, and from the video posted to Reddit, it can clearly be seen that there is no human behind the wheel of the Waymo vehicle. Although the title of the post is “Self-driving car parks in intersection and blocks traffic,” the tech company disagrees with that characterization of the incident.

To begin with, a Waymo spokesperson told us that it was the bus, not the company’s robotaxi, that started the incident by reversing back into an intersection that it had already turned through.

“Though unclear why, passengers began exiting the bus within about 15 seconds of the bus stopping in the intersection,” the spokesperson said. “At that point, it was clear that the bus would not begin moving again and that our vehicle would need to take a different route.

The company further claims that, although the vehicle did stop in the intersection, it was only parked there for about one minute, after which it navigated around the bus, and through the intersection."

Source: Waymo Autonomous Car And Bus Block Intersection In San Francisco - But Who Was To Blame? | Carscoops
 
Waymo software update to go with expansion:

In addition to the expansion, Waymo One is implementing key software updates to increase the reliability and usability of the service:
  • Riders should experience improved pick-ups and drop-offs and more confident, predictable driving maneuvers.
  • Pedestrians should have more human-like interactions with our vehicles, as we plan to start adding new ways for vehicles to communicate intent with other road users through audio and visual cues.
  • A plethora of other back-end improvements should also result in more consistent driving performance and fleet efficiencies.
To service such a large area and better accommodate longer trips, Waymo One continues to test its vehicles on the freeway with employees and an autonomous specialist behind the wheel.

Source: Waymo One expands another 45 square miles in Metro Phoenix - AZ Big Media

The part about audio and visual cues to communicate intent with road users is especially interesting to me. This should help a lot in various interactions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Doggydogworld
They could use the speaker to offer a free ride to whomever removes the cone from the hood of the car. Cheaper than sending a service tech to do it.

I doubt the person would accept a free ride since they put the cone on the car in the first place as a protest against Waymo. I would think remote assistance could probably tell the Waymo to move until the cone falls off. Furthermore, Waymo is likely coming up with a software fix so that the cone trick does not stop the car. Waymo could use the external speaker to warn the person against putting the cone on the car. A message like "you are being recorded with cameras. If you put the cone on the car, the police will be notified" could deter some people.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cwerdna
vandalism: willful or malicious destruction or defacement of public or private property

Doesn't sound like vandalism to me, as there is no destruction or defacement of the property.

That's like saying anyone protesting by blocking the road is vandalizing the road.
Cone theft? I doubt the protester owns the cone. Perhaps a OSHA safety violation created by removing a cone marking a workplace hazard?
 
vandalism: willful or malicious destruction or defacement of public or private property

Doesn't sound like vandalism to me, as there is no destruction or defacement of the property.

That's like saying anyone protesting by blocking the road is vandalizing the road.
Since the ‘damage’ is trivially reversible I doubt a vandalism charge is going to stick.

What would someone who placed a traffic cone in a normal road to disrupt traffic be charged with? The law is not going to have any special distinction just because it’s an AV.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bkp_duke
What would someone who placed a traffic cone in a normal road to disrupt traffic be charged with?
Blocking traffic, I would assume (as with protests). It's a misdemeanor in most jurisdictions, but can come with a fine or even jail time. Then there's the whole thing about disrupting the operation of a business, and possibly the damage to the business from a perception standpoint. Kinda like painting a mustache on a billboard.

I wonder if protesters blocking traffic could be hit with a collective lawsuit by everyone who got caught up in the resulting traffic.

I am not a lawyer.
 
Since the ‘damage’ is trivially reversible I doubt a vandalism charge is going to stick.

What would someone who placed a traffic cone in a normal road to disrupt traffic be charged with? The law is not going to have any special distinction just because it’s an AV.

Putting cones into traffic might count as Disturbing the Peace, but it would be at the lowest end of that charge ($200 fine, no jail time).

However, purposefully removing traffic cones from a construction site is Theft and might get a Reckless Endangerment charge if enough are removed, which may involve jail time. If I was a California lawyer being paid for a consult, I'd probably recommend the protesters buy cheap traffic cones ($15) rather than removing them from other locations. Tossing a $2 towel over a few sensors would probably also disable the vehicle, though don't damage the spinning lidar as it wouldn't take much to reach a felony ($400 in damage).
 
Last edited:
Waymo adds another 45 sq mi to their metro Phoenix area:


Some of the additions, like the south-west edge, are quite subtle on the map.

I would guess they intended to include at least some of this area in their expansion 2 months ago, but had technical issues preventing it at that time.

Old:
waymo-may2023.png


New:
waymo-phx-map-july2023.png;w=960;h=640;bgcolor=000000