Uh oh, I bought my CPO P85D 4 months ago, and let's just say I may have overpaid
.. Regardless I lOVE IT!
All that matters is that you love it!!
Pricing and condition is all subjective as everyone has different standards for what they are willing to pay for different condition vehicles. Like the OP, i did not expect perfection, but major damage was my concern. I saw a few in the $55-$60 range all with some level of damage or flaws.
The only way to really get a deal is if you are able and patient enough to watch one drop from $65-$70 down below $60.
Looking at history. Mine started at $68, and kept dropping. I guess the missing features (21”wheels, red calipers, dual charger) and color combo (black w Grey interior) was not attractive to most.
On the other hand. The one I originally placed a deposit on. Showed history of starting at $59 dropped, some put a deposit, came back at $57, I put a deposit, came back at 57, dropped to $55 and is still there!
The more I am researching, I think they price accordingly to condition and drop at standard (or random intervals).
This is just theory, but maybe it helps those hunting for a CPO (I mean used Tesla).