TMC is an independent, primarily volunteer organization that relies on ad revenue to cover its operating costs. Please consider whitelisting TMC on your ad blocker or making a Paypal contribution here: paypal.me/SupportTMC

No brake llights above 136 kph (85 mph) while using regen braking

Discussion in 'Model S: Driving Dynamics' started by slcuervo, Nov 27, 2015.

  1. slcuervo

    slcuervo Member

    Joined:
    Sep 26, 2014
    Messages:
    266
    Location:
    Norway
    #1 slcuervo, Nov 27, 2015
    Last edited by a moderator: Mar 13, 2016
    No brake lights above 136 kph (85 mph) while using regen braking

    Hello guys,

    I have recently crossed Germany twice with my Model S, and noticed that the brake lights do not go on when using full regen (above 60 kW). They of course work when braking with the brake pedal, but not with regen if above 136 kph or 85 mph.

    I believe this is serious, it is a safety issue. What if someone is tailing us? You all know the amount of deceleration applied is huge, equivalent to pedal braking. And if brake lights do not go on under such deceleration, the car following us can rear end our Model S and cause a serious accident.

    I have recorded a video where I explain this and show exactly what I am talking about:



    What are your thoughts?

    I suppose German owners will have more to say about this, but I am sure some of them read TMC forums...
     
    • Like x 1
  2. islandbayy

    islandbayy Active Member

    Joined:
    Feb 25, 2013
    Messages:
    2,018
    Location:
    Greendale, Wisconsin
    It's not a problem. The regen brake lights are based on rate of decel. Once the rate of decel is high enough, they will activate. If this was not the case, they would be coming on any time you took your foot off the accelerator. Which would be quite annoying.
     
  3. slcuervo

    slcuervo Member

    Joined:
    Sep 26, 2014
    Messages:
    266
    Location:
    Norway
    I know that´s the way the system works. However, I had the opportunity to try it uphill too, and even though I did not record it, I can assure you that the car´s behavior was the same. No brake lights until 136 kph (or 85 mph) was reached, and then they turned on. This is, in fact, what made me do the video, because it showed me that it looks like they´ve set some sort of limit at 85 mph, and it does not depend on the deceleration force above that speed.

    Below 85 mph that´s exactly how it works: if the rate of decel is high enough, the lights go on. But it seems to be different above 85 mph, I don´t know why...
     
  4. ecarfan

    ecarfan Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Sep 21, 2013
    Messages:
    10,402
    Location:
    San Mateo, CA
    Being in California I don't drive over 85mph but I suspect the answer to your question is that at such high speeds, when you lift your foot off the "go" pedal the Model S slows down gradually like an ICE car would (without the driver touching the brake pedal). So no reason for the S brake lights to come on. At speeds under 85 the Model S deceleration is more abrupt when you lift you foot off the go pedal, so the brake lights are activated.
    So that's my theory. Not able to test it out here, legally...
     
  5. David99

    David99 Active Member

    Joined:
    Jan 31, 2014
    Messages:
    2,066
    Location:
    Brea, Orange County
    I understand the concern, but as others have said, the brake light don't come on on any other car either when you lift off the accelerator at high speed. the rate of deceleration is probably similar.

    What people often don't understand is the rate of acceleration and deceleration depends greatly on speed, not just how much power is applied. 40 kw gives you a decent amount of acceleration from a stop, but it does very little once you go 70. the same is true for deceleration. 40 kW of regen at 70 mph isn't much. At 20 mph that would be a very strong force slowing you down. The energy needed to accelerator or decelerate a 10 mph difference is very different depending on your speed. So 60 kW of regen at 90 mph isn't that much, hence the brake light won't come on. At 50 mph the same 60 kW of regen will slow your car down much stronger, and the brake lights come on.

    To avoid the effect of having very low deceleration at higher speed and then getting stronger and stronger as you slow down, Tesla modulates the regen power down as the car slows down. The regen power is reduced but the rate of deceleration stays (roughly) the same.
     
  6. sorka

    sorka Active Member

    Joined:
    Feb 28, 2015
    Messages:
    3,269
    Location:
    Merced, CA
    I can assure you the rate of deceleration is much greater as speeds increase.

    When letting off the throttle at various speeds with my vbox:

    92 MPH = 0.336 g
    74 MPH = 0.144 g
    68 MPH = 0.133 g
    65 MPH = 0.127 g


    Since air resistance is proportional to V^2, letting off at 150 MPH would probably be close to 0.7 g.

    Maybe there's some regulation that prevents the light from coming on for regen above 85 MPH, but it doesn't seem the safest choice.
     
    • Helpful x 1
  7. slcuervo

    slcuervo Member

    Joined:
    Sep 26, 2014
    Messages:
    266
    Location:
    Norway
    Thanks sorka for your inputs. It adds a lot of value to my statements, which are only based on perception, really.

    I've been thinking about this issue for some time now, and I've been reading a lot about it.

    I know 60 kW do not slow down a car going 90 mph as much as it slows down one going 30 mph, and I therefore understand why brake ligths don't go on based on the amount of kW of regen, but rather on deceleration force.

    However, what triggered my video, what pushed me to upload it, was the fact that I tried the deceleration from 170 kph (around 105 mph) going uphill, and the lights were off until speed reached 136 kph (85 mph). And it's just too bad I could not record it, but the deceleration rate had to be much higher, since I was going uphill. And still no brake lights.
     
  8. jpet

    jpet Jan P.

    Joined:
    Aug 8, 2014
    Messages:
    3,288
    Location:
    Herne & Leuven, BE
    Slcuervo, just went out and did some tests. My car does not have the issue. I tested it at various speeds up to approximately 175 km/h (110 mph).
    What version of the firmware are you running? I'm now on 2.7.77 and I have an auto-pilot equipped car.
    Could it be that this issue is limited to classic versions of the Model S?
    I agree that it is an important safety issue.
     
  9. kennybobby

    kennybobby Member

    Joined:
    Sep 14, 2014
    Messages:
    479
    Location:
    Heart o' Dixie
    try it going downhill--i'd guess it will apply greater regen braking.
     
  10. slcuervo

    slcuervo Member

    Joined:
    Sep 26, 2014
    Messages:
    266
    Location:
    Norway
    2.7.77 too, non AP.

    I hope it's all non AP cars and not only mine!
     
  11. slcuervo

    slcuervo Member

    Joined:
    Sep 26, 2014
    Messages:
    266
    Location:
    Norway
    If you mean greater deceleration, no it won't. The rate will be smaller because going downhill will result in lower decrease of speed.

    If you're talking about the amount of kW of regen, it stays the same, be it on a flat road, or uphill/downhill - provided that the battery conditions are similar
     
  12. roblab

    roblab Active Member

    Joined:
    Jul 15, 2008
    Messages:
    2,038
    Location:
    Angwin (Napa Valley) CA
    How can this be an issue??

    Who in the world will be following you when you are doing 85, and why would you want your brake lights to go on? Are they tail gating and you want them to back off?

    I live in CA, and I DO drive 85. It's pretty common. I have found, actually, that when in cruise and passing someone over 90 mph, the car beeps at you, because cruise does not go over 90. But I don't care what the brake lights are doing. I don't think someone is going to hit me from behind at that speed. My gas car never did have brake lights go on.

    You ought to do your deceleration g forces on a gas car and see what they are. With a manual tranny, it slows down pretty fast.

    I had a guy get all perturbed because my brake lights didn't go on when I was coasting to a red light. He saw it was a Tesla, followed me into the parking lot and yelled at me. I asked him if his lights went on while he was coasting. People are supposed to slow when cars are in front, with or without lights.
     
  13. jerry33

    jerry33 S85 - VIN:P05130 - 3/2/13

    Joined:
    Mar 8, 2012
    Messages:
    12,766
    Location:
    Texas
    In Texas it doesn't matter what speed you travel at, there will always be someone right on your tail.
     
  14. jpet

    jpet Jan P.

    Joined:
    Aug 8, 2014
    Messages:
    3,288
    Location:
    Herne & Leuven, BE
    Ok, thanks. I will get it confirmed by some European non AP drivers so that you know if it is specific to your car. Might take 24 hours since it is already late at night over here. Had to do my testing in the dark as well.
     
  15. slcuervo

    slcuervo Member

    Joined:
    Sep 26, 2014
    Messages:
    266
    Location:
    Norway
    Like I said in the video, it's pretty common in Europe, especially in German motorways without speed limit.

    I am just thinking of brake lights to warn them that I am decelerating strongly and to avoid an accident. I don't want to get rear ended.

    If they go on below 85 mph at full regen, why not above that speed? That's my point.
     
  16. sorka

    sorka Active Member

    Joined:
    Feb 28, 2015
    Messages:
    3,269
    Location:
    Merced, CA
    Just because ICE cars don't light up their brake lights when engine and air braking doesn't mean they shouldn't. Tesla is one of the first cars to turn on brake lights in response to something other than a brake pedal being pressed past a certain point.

    I think cars should light up their brake lights when they exceed a certain level of deceleration whether it be from physical brakes, regen braking, engine braking, air braking or any combination that exceeds a certain rate of deceleration.

    Indeed others have been designing solutions around just that:

    Motorcycle brake lighting system doesnre slowing down
    GearBrake - Smart Brake Light Moduleâ„¢
    Adaptive Brake Light (ABL) - The 3rd Eye
     
  17. AWDtsla

    AWDtsla Active Member

    Joined:
    Mar 3, 2013
    Messages:
    2,144
    Location:
    NE
    But clearly the proportion of deceleration due to regen becomes a smaller amount of the total deceleration.

    IMHO I'd rather not have my brake lights come on when coming down from extra-legal speeds. Flashing brake lights give away your former speed on the highway. This happens often if you drive a manual, with no brake lights.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Brake lights are just a hint, you are supposed to be in control of your speed and observe what's in front of you at all times. "His brake lights weren't on" would never pass as a defense, if you rear end a car you are responsible. Which is also why in Germany tail-gating is the ultimate roadway sin.
     
  18. jerry33

    jerry33 S85 - VIN:P05130 - 3/2/13

    Joined:
    Mar 8, 2012
    Messages:
    12,766
    Location:
    Texas
    Most of my cars have been either manual or semi-automatic. No brake lights when gearing down in those. Of the three times I was rear ended, two were when the car was parked, and the other was in a car that was an automatic. Never had any problems with no brake lights in a standard transmission car while actually driving.
     
  19. AudubonB

    AudubonB Mild-mannered Moderator Lord Vetinari*

    Joined:
    Mar 24, 2013
    Messages:
    4,255
    Location:
    Denali Highway, Alaska
    To slcuervo: have you been able to ascertain your claim by having another tail you and let you know yea/nay wrt your brake lights? I would wonder if any problem that might exist COULD be solely in the dashboard display.

    To the overall point, however: I would suggest that any responsible driver who is interested in decelerating a vehicle going 135kph/85mph....should very most definitely make use of the brake pedal.
     
  20. sillydriver

    sillydriver Member

    Joined:
    Oct 19, 2014
    Messages:
    542
    Location:
    Middleburg, va
    Sorka -- interesting data on these deceleration rates.

    As you say, the force and hence the contribution to deceleration (in Gs) of air drag goes as v^2. On the other hand, the contribution to deceleration (in Gs) of the maximum regen level in kW goes as 1/v. The point is, the higher the speed, the lower the contribution of regen as a % of total deceleration when you lift. I suspect the brake lights don't go on unless either the total Gs due to regen is over some threshold, or the percentage of the total deceleration due to regen is over some threshold, neither of which condition can be met at very high speed. Why is this okay? Because when you lift your foot in the limiting case of extremely high speed, a Tesla with regen won't decelerate at a significantly higher rate than an ICE car, even though the absolute deceleration of both is high due to air drag. Since it's okay for ICE cars not put on the brake lights upon lifting at high speed, Tesla's thought must be that it's also okay for a MS, which would only be decelerating at a slightly higher rate.
     

Share This Page