Punctured tire/question

[E2KK6N]

Hello,

I just got a low pressure notification and discovered a screw has punctured my front passenger tire. I’ve only had my Y 3 months. Checked recommendations online, and I see in the app I can order a replacement. Elsewhere online someone recommended a patch kit. Questions:

- Is the car diagram in the app an overhead view/meaning the front right tire in the app is the same as the front passenger tire?
- if I use the app to replace, I see something about install too - is it shipped to me and I replace myself, or will the app require I go to the service center to replace? (I’m on a lease)
- or has someone done this patch kit thing, which I am not a fan of doing, and I think because the tire is losing pressure, the puncture has gone all the way the way through?

Thanks in advance for any advice!

 

[GHammer]

Take it to your local tire shop, if it's repairable let them repair it, if not buy a new one from them. There's nothing magical about Tesla tires.

 

[buddhafree]

It really depends where the puncture is. If it's on the side or too close to sidewall then it needs replacement.
I would recommend to either check with your local tire shop or identify the puncture yourself to see if it can be fixed before ordering new tire.

 

[fholbert]

Hello,

I just got a low pressure notification and discovered a screw has punctured my front passenger tire. I’ve only had my Y 3 months. Checked recommendations online, and I see in the app I can order a replacement. Elsewhere online someone recommended a patch kit. Questions:

- Is the car diagram in the app an overhead view/meaning the front right tire in the app is the same as the front passenger tire?
- if I use the app to replace, I see something about install too - is it shipped to me and I replace myself, or will the app require I go to the service center to replace? (I’m on a lease)
- or has someone done this patch kit thing, which I am not a fan of doing, and I think because the tire is losing pressure, the puncture has gone all the way the way through?

Thanks in advance for any advice!

America’s Tire (aka Discount Tire) is your friend.

Discount Tire | Tires and Wheels for Sale | Online & In-Person

www.americastire.com

 

[redpoint5]

Buy a $2 tire plug kit, pull the screw out with pliers, and permanently fix the leak in like 5 minutes without taking the wheel off the car. Thank me later.

 

[Watts_Up]

Tire Repair Kit​

A tire repair kit, saved my weekend trip !!!

 

[Calliope]

Buy a $2 tire plug kit, pull the screw out with pliers, and permanently fix the leak in like 5 minutes without taking the wheel off the car.

Depending on where the screw is. I have a kit in my car, but it won't help in some locations.

 

[GHammer]

Buy a $2 tire plug kit, pull the screw out with pliers, and permanently fix the leak in like 5 minutes without taking the wheel off the car. Thank me later.

Tire Repair Kit​

View attachment 1037590

A tire repair kit, saved my weekend trip !!!

Depending on where the screw is. I have a kit in my car, but it won't help in some locations.

I have trouble recommending a DIY fix to someone who is already having issues figuring out how to get someone else to do it.

 

[redpoint5]

I have trouble recommending a DIY fix to someone who is already having issues figuring out how to get someone else to do it.

My comments are often rhetorical to the OP, but meant for the larger audience.

That said, I still encourage people to at least try their own repair considering how frequently punctures occur, and how simple it is to recover from it. Worst case they wasted 10 minutes and $2 on a tire repair kit.

 

[holmesm1]

Hello,

I just got a low pressure notification and discovered a screw has punctured my front passenger tire. I’ve only had my Y 3 months. Checked recommendations online, and I see in the app I can order a replacement. Elsewhere online someone recommended a patch kit. Questions:

- Is the car diagram in the app an overhead view/meaning the front right tire in the app is the same as the front passenger tire?
- if I use the app to replace, I see something about install too - is it shipped to me and I replace myself, or will the app require I go to the service center to replace? (I’m on a lease)
- or has someone done this patch kit thing, which I am not a fan of doing, and I think because the tire is losing pressure, the puncture has gone all the way the way through?

Thanks in advance for any advice!

I went to Discount Tire, fully expecting to be charged for the screw in my tire, but they repaired it for free even though it was an OEM tire not purchased from them. Of course this assumes it is repairable and has no damage to the sidewall.

 

[sidewinder]

just plugged mine other day and so far no bubbles and holding air. its borderline sidewall but it was a clean puncture so i expect it to hold and carry the plug kit and tools if it springs a leak. tire has 12k on it and hopefully will last.

used this kit. also available at walmart.

https://www.amazon.com/Slime-20049-Pressure-Gauge-Analogue/dp/B000ET9SAA

 

[BroncoAZ]

just plugged mine other day and so far no bubbles and holding air. its borderline sidewall but it was a clean puncture so i expect it to hold and carry the plug kit and tools if it springs a leak. tire has 12k on it and hopefully will last.

used this kit. also available at walmart.

https://www.amazon.com/Slime-20049-Pressure-Gauge-Analogue/dp/B000ET9SAA

View attachment 1037853View attachment 1037854

That shoulder area of the tire is not approved for repair, the tire should be replaced. At least make sure it’s mounted on the rear where a blowout is less severe.

 

[fiehlsport]

With that said, it'll safely last the life of the tire. They just do.

 

[redpoint5]

That shoulder area of the tire is not approved for repair, the tire should be replaced. At least make sure it’s mounted on the rear where a blowout is less severe.

Who experiences "a blowout" due to a failed repair? The only time I've experienced "a blowout" is when my car is hurtling through the air, or otherwise smashing violently into obstacles only maniacs hit.

Worst case, the repair is insufficient, causing a gradual reduction in pressure, necessitating replacement at some point.

 

[turnbowm]

That shoulder area of the tire is not approved for repair, the tire should be replaced. At least make sure it’s mounted on the rear where a blowout is less severe.

It'a actually safer to put the repaired tire on the front. You have steering control of the front but no control of the rear.

Brand New Tires Belong on the Back of Your Car | Torrance Personal Injury and Sexual Abuse Lawyer | Los Angeles Metro Area

booth.law

 

[BroncoAZ]

It'a actually safer to put the repaired tire on the front. You have steering control of the front but no control of the rear.

Brand New Tires Belong on the Back of Your Car | Torrance Personal Injury and Sexual Abuse Lawyer | Los Angeles Metro Area

booth.law

Having experienced complete failures (shredded tire) at highway speeds both front and rear, I found the rear blowout significantly easier to control. The loss of the front tire caused the vehicle to violently change direction and swerve into the other lane before I had a chance to react. The rear blowout was noticeable but not at all severe allowing me to safety pull over without drama. Since the rear is following the front the other rear tire keeps the back of the car in line with the steering input.

 

[turnbowm]

Having experienced complete failures (shredded tire) at highway speeds both front and rear, I found the rear blowout significantly easier to control. The loss of the front tire caused the vehicle to violently change direction and swerve into the other lane before I had a chance to react. The rear blowout was noticeable but not at all severe allowing me to safety pull over without drama. Since the rear is following the front the other rear tire keeps the back of the car in line with the steering

"Countless crash test studies prove that it is much easier to maintain control over a vehicle if it is the front tire that suffers a blowout. That’s because even if there is are major tire defects causing the blowout, you’ll still have the ability to steer the vehicle."

Tips for Handling a Tire Blowout | Travelers Insurance

How you handle a tire blowout can make a difference in preventing an accident. Learn how to handle a tire blowout, tire blowout causes and more from Travelers.

www.travelers.com

 

[redpoint5]

@John in LBYou going to share your knowledge with others, or keep it secret?

 

[John in LB]

Basically, others have said what needs to be said:
1) have a tire shop try to patch the hole (not just plug).
2) Must be inside the steel belt area (not near edge or sidewall).
3) General data says a blow out in rear is worse than front... but there are a lot of factors that affect that prognosis
(front to rear axel weight ratio, center of gravity)
4) These are heavy cars - don't take condition of tires lightly.

Speaking of which, I had to replace one of my rear tires due to curb damage on the inside - happen to find it during rotation/balance. Here is a photo... After tire was removed from wheel, I poked it with my finger and it bulged like a balloon...

 

[redpoint5]

Basically, others have said what needs to be said:

I appreciate the response and attention to safety. That said, you don't know anyone who has died from a tire plug failure. You don't know anyone who knows someone who died of a tire plug failure.

We're going to die like everyone else; from heart disease or cancer. Anyone who is fearful of a tire plug, yet part of the 80% of Americans who are overweight have their fears misplaced.

Go ahead and spend a fortune and ton of time for "experts" who don't care about you, your car, and get paid near minimum wage to fix a puncture you're capable of addressing in 5 minutes for twenty cents in materials because you imagine tire plug failure is your demise, instead of high cholesterol and a malfunctioning endocrine system.