Is it a good idea, or for peace of the mind, to carry a spare tire for long distance road trip? Any nightmarish flat tire incident you ever encountered that made you wish you should have carried one in your trunk?
You can install our site as a web app on your iOS device by utilizing the Add to Home Screen feature in Safari. Please see this thread for more details on this.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I just carry a plug kit and so far I haven't had to use it on trips. Around town I've had six flats, two of which were tire destroying. I'm not happy that there isn't a spare, but I'm also not happy about the space that a spare would take up as there is no special place for it.
I have 19" tires. However, I'm in DFW. I've never had so many flats as I have had since moving here. Type of car doesn't matter.OP - what type of tires do you have? The 21's are susceptible to blowouts on potholes
@jerry33 - I'm guessing you have 21's?
I've got >53k miles in my car with one flat (screw). I'd suggest a pump and repair kit which is what I have.
Having lived in Canada for many years, I can safely say that Canada keeps it's roads far cleaner than the U.S. I now feel lucky when we don't have four flats per year (between our two cars). I agree that the unfortunate trend of wide low profile tires makes it much more difficult to carry a spare.Statistically very few spare tires in new vehicles are ever used. They also weigh a lot, and take up a lot of space. We don't carry spares for almost anything else that could leave you stranded, so why the tire? It made sense decades ago to carry a spare tire, but due to improvements in tire design it does not today. As a result, most manufacturers are starting to sell at least some of their cars without spare tires, and I would be surprised if in the very near future that didn't expand to all new vehicles.
I outfitted our Model S with a universal tire iron and a compact scissor jack. We also have a set of snow tires on wheels. Whenever we go on a long trip or drive somewhere remote, I toss one of the other tires into the car. It comes out when we get home.
Recently did a trip to Utah over the holidays. Was a bit annoying to have this massive 21" wheel and tire floating around in back with our stuff, but was less annoying that potentially getting a flat somewhere out in the sticks and having to wait hours in the cold for a tow truck.
Search the forums for "Spare tire", I think someone's figured out that the BMW X5 compact spare works for the Model S, and fits easily in the frunk of the RWD Model S.
I have one i bought at a local auto/hardware store (Canadian Tire), it consists of a few strands of cord that are covered in a tar like substance, and 2 tools, a sort of file or rasp, and an insertion tool. When you puncture a tire you listen for where the air is escaping, or look for where the screw/nail is still in the tire, (the usual situation.) One you've found it, you remove the screw/nail (I also carry a multi tool) and insert the file/rasp in to the hole while turning it in one direction. You then remove the file/rasp while continuing to turn it the same direction. Next you thread one of the cords through the insertion tool, push it straight in to the hole, and pull the tool straight back out. Then use a compressor to top up the tire.I've been on the fence about whether to buy an extra tire but I definitely see the point of keeping as much space available as possible. For those who don't have a spare but use plug kits and such, would you be willing to talk more about what you use, how it has worked for you and where you got them (Amazon link)? Thanks!
I haven't had a flat tire in 20 years. (probably just jinxed myself). On all my ICE cars that had spare tires, I never used them.
That being said, I was kinda worried when I placed my order that the tesla didn't come with a spare. But after 75000km and roadtrips to Montreal and Chicago where I haven't run into any flat tire incidences, I never think about it.
Having lived in Canada for many years, I can safely say that Canada keeps it's roads far cleaner than the U.S. I now feel lucky when we don't have four flats per year (between our two cars). I agree that the unfortunate trend of wide low profile tires makes it much more difficult to carry a spare.
Quebec roads are horrible, there's no doubt there, but I don't think it's in the "flat tire" way, it's more in the "I need a new suspension" way...Define "Canada". Western Canadian roads are generally good. Ontario and Atlantic are fair (save Toronto - bad ), but Quebec roads are a disaster. Quebec's bridges are even worse......
Almost everywhere west of Thunder Bay. I've only been to Toronto and Montreal a couple of times. Interestingly, I have some Canadian co-workers (from Toronto) and they have mentioned the same thing about the amount of flats they now get.Define "Canada". Western Canadian roads are generally good. Ontario and Atlantic are fair (save Toronto - bad ), but Quebec roads are a disaster. Quebec's bridges are even worse......
Saskatchewan's roads have been horrible for decades, and are getting worse every year.Define "Canada". Western Canadian roads are generally good. Ontario and Atlantic are fair (save Toronto - bad ), but Quebec roads are a disaster. Quebec's bridges are even worse......