MangroveMike
Member
Argh this ranking irks me. They cite the lack of charging infrastructure as the reason the Tesla lost out on first spot, because it doesn't give "freedom" in some cases. This is just absolutely bogus and reflects old world thinking. Electric cars give you MORE freedom because you wake up every day with a full charge. It's more convenient. It gives us freedom from foreign oil. Not to mention that it gives 99% of drivers the same range freedom as an ICE 95% of the time. To say that you lose out on car of the year because of the tiny percentage of people who drive more than 50km a day, or that tiny percentage of your life when you'll take a huge road trip, is just ridiculous. It's driven by fear, not logic.
I know Tesla have done supremely well just to make the list, but at the same time I hate seeing the same reasons come up again and again, when they have very little basis in reality.
I see where you are coming from Tim and agree with my rose-coloured glasses on, but I think based upon a decision today, that they have probably got it right. In a years time I think that a lot of these grievances will be addressed as the SuperChargers roll out to increase the range and limitations that we as early adopters will have for the first few months of ownership.
When the Model S received the Car and Driver award last year in the US there were already quite a few (50+, I think) superchargers in the states. That would have worked greatly in it's favour.