I just saw an interview with Tom Nichols, author of
The Death of Expertise, on Amanpour & Company (PBS). He pointed out that in the pre-internet days there were towns where there might be 1 person out of 10,000 who thought, for instance, that the moon landing was faked. That person would be regarded as a flake or ignored and that would be that. But today social media lets those people connect with like-minded people in towns all over the world, and now they can feed off each other and gain support they otherwise wouldn't have. Combine that with the self-publishing capabilities of the internet and you can get a movement. That's my view of much of TSLAQ. The short seller pros like Chanos and Einhorn are glad to leverage this hungry-to-have-their-biases-confirmed community to get the word out.
Although, as I pointed out in a previous post, at least one prominent TSLAQ member (
TeslaCharts) bases his views on reasonable data. It's pretty clear today that Musk's solar roof reveal at the movie studio (the old set of Desperate Housewives in fact) was at best overhyped and most likely a misrepresentation of the state of development at the time (see the
FastCompany article). It took almost 3 years to get to a viable product. I also agree with TC's view that the Solar City acquisition was, in reality, a rescue of a failing company and not in the best interests of TSLA shareholders. So, I understand where TC's coming from. And if you take the time to listen to that podcast, you'll hear him try not to embarrass the host of the podcast, who goes off the deep end by being anti-everything related to Musk, Tesla, EVs, solar, batteries - at one point saying that EVs are foolish, to which TC responds that he himself owns a Chevy EV, so he's not anti-EV nor anti-US companies. It's kind of fun in a weird way. So, we need to be careful not to paint all of TSLAQ with the same brush.
However, TeslaCharts let the Solar City demo episode (he calls it a "realization") taint his view not only of Musk, but of all of Tesla. And once he donned those smoke-colored glasses, he now sees bad in everything Musk touches. For all his faults, at least TeslaCharts is self-aware, as his Twitter summary is: "
Catnip for TSLA bears. Not investment advice. Disclosure: Short TSLA via put options". Heck, in the podcast TC himself talked about social media being a new tool for shorters - no longer do they have to rely on relationships with specific journalists to get their word out (read up on Chanos and Fairfax if you want to know how they used to do it, including either paying journalists to write articles or at least getting a heads-up on an article before it was released). Now that the pros can leverage amateur wanna-be's they have a much easier time getting nonsense published.
I do think the days of TSLAQ are coming to an end, probably with TSLA is added to the S&P 500 later this year.