Well, I would not call it "fair overall". Consider this part:
To explain the behavior, Mr. Musk told the court he didn’t respect Mr. Baron because the lawyer had once worked at a law firm whose partners became engulfed in an ethics scandal. “I think you are a bad human being,” Mr. Musk said to Mr. Baron.
I mean that's one way to describe it if you want minimize his comments as some cheap stab at the lawyer's past. In reality, though, if you dig up the stories Elon was referring to, as I am sure someone like the WSJ should do as a reputable news organization, you will find that:
- The first company Baron was working for Milberg Weiss: the two name partners got sentenced to jail after a court has found that through their 150 cases, they have earned 216 million dollars by paying 11 million in bribes to witnesses and experts. they have also laundered 44 million bucks and were found guilty in 3x mail fraud.
- Then our good friend went to work for another company, Robbins Geller, where later on, the partners got jailed and as recently as this May, that company was thrown off a case by a court after it found the law firm failed to disclose their class action clients were actually shorting the company they were suing.
So yeah, that is the work history of our standup citizen, Mr. Randy Baron here - I am sure this is just a coincidence, bad choice of law firms in a difficult jobs market, he is a decent guy. So it is perfectly fair to refer to this as "he has once worked for a firm where there were some shady people".