I disagree but welcome your financial proof. Show your account balance, share your trading thoughts, show trades.
On 2/23, around $640, I bought a large lot (for me = 40 contracts) of July 1000 calls based on:
1. Confirmation of demand zone from 12/22-12/23
2. Confirmation of the trend line from August (the shallower slope one screenshot above)
3. Confirmation of support from 200MA
4. IV30 jumping out of a "post corona low" trough and IV120 making a step up
5. Confirmation of SPY trend line from 10/30
The decision to go 1000 was primarily because I wanted to limit my downside exposure with lower ∆. That's admittedly a pretty round number; I'm actually working with my trading partner to develop a tool to optimize strike selection so I may not make that same choice in the future.
On 3/4, again around ~$640, I bought 10 June 800 calls across a number of accounts based on:
4. Confirmation of a double bottom from 2/23
5. ~4% recovery from the day low (615)
6. Further rising volatility
7. Confirmation of SPY bottom from 1/19-2/1
The decision to go 800 (and a month closer than above) was because I had stronger conviction based on #4-#7 and so wanted a little more ∆/$.
All total I bought 50 contracts; obviously both entries were too early. Currently the 800's are up ~60% and the 1000s are up 7.05%.
As another example, on 12/29, around $660, I bought large lot (again for me, this time 50x) of July 1000 calls based on:
1. Post-corona volatility coming off a low
2. Volatility speculation going into earnings
3. Speculation on an upside move out of a short term consolidation
4. Speculation on a break out of a short term downtrend line
5. SPY making an ATH
Going DOTM was again to hedge against my speculation with a relatively low ∆. The contracts were progressively stopped out and then purposely closed leading up to earnings at about ~350% profit.
As a final example, on 1/15 I bough another large lot (50x--seems like that's typical for me, but its not) of March $1000's based on:
1. A big down day
2. A big drop in volatility
3. Speculation on consolidation and a subsequent breakout.
In hindsight this wasn't a very sensible trade as it didn't have super strong indicators and was really me just getting greedy. I closed out ~2 weeks later at ~5% profit.
Show me anyone using TA to get the greatest results...
Technical analysis does not live in a vacuum, it is simply a part of what
should be a diversified approach to The Market, where 'diversified' is a concept that lives on a very wide spectrum. Because one's methods of analysis, short and long term goals, risk tolerance, etc. all rack up into a very personalized strategy, something like "the greatest results" are meaningless metrics to anyone but that trader. Some folks, for instance, aim to minimize balance drawdown instead of maximizing position profit, and it would be seriously dismissive to suggest those folks aren't going for
the greatest results.