I vote for 1, blue with grey leather, as that's what I'll be getting
And the carbon grey wheels look fabulous on a blue S, this is IMHO the best color for the performance wheels.
I aslo share your optinion on the tan. Nothing brown or any shades thereof for me, thanks.
Black interiors tend to feel cramped and somewhat depressing to me, while a light greys feels "open" and airy. Also the two-tone door interiors look much better than black only