if I wasn’t saving for a Tesla, I’d not have
any capital gains. The whole purpose of buying the stock is to buy a Tesla later.
Now, if it does well enough, I may not sell all of it. But even were I to keep them, I have so few that if the stock was 1k I’d still only be in the five digits,
including my initial investment.
So, small apples.
If you keep the stock and defer the car(or lease it) you might be able to buy a fleet of Tesla's in the future ... a Tesla vehicle is still a depreciating asset... no matter what Elon says ... and if I am wrong and it turns out that Tesla's are appreciating assets (As EM suggests) ... then you will be that much richer the more shares you hold long ...
your signature indicates a P100D ? If you are really "poor" do you really need such an expensive Tesla i sure you can get in a model 3/Y for a lot less with less taxes, insurance and depreciation ... depreciation for MS is pretty significant... I looked into selling mine ....and the used prices for MS are no where near initial new car prices...in fact if you are "poor" don't buy a new car at all
don't get me wrong I want everyone to own a Tesla ... but only when it makes financial sense ...
Lets assume 2 options on how to use $100,000 worth of Tesla shares (over simplified hypothetical example ):
1)Sell Shares to purchase P100D you then have to pay taxes on gains either short term capital gains or long term depending on how long you have owned the shares.
Buy P100D at $ 94,000 USD plus taxes/delivery/ etc. round to $100,000
after 5 years P100D is worth
$50,000...(probably optimistic) plus you will pay for Insurance for 5 years (Model S is very expensive to insure)
2) Hold $100,000 worth of Tesla Shares(186 shares) , you have no taxable event.
Bull Case : Ark Invest 5 year target price is now $6000 that is $5462 over today's closing price of $538. Those shares in 5 years could be
$1,015,241.
Middle Case lets be more conservative assume $2000 share price in 5 years =
$271,932
Bear Case :lets be really pessimistic in 5 years the stock is $538 then you have
$100,000... and I would argue that if Tesla is $538 in 5 years from now then we are in a deep global recession or Tesla failed in some way to capitalize on the advantages it possesses in 2020.
again not advice ... sorry about the rant but I hate to witness financial miscues...this was partially for my own therapy as i was thinking about selling shares to buy a new P100D ... conclusion is right now it makes no sense ... granted i have a Telsa ... why not consider a M3 or MY and keep more shares for the long run... I think in 5 years i will get the Performance MS and the Cybertruck but i need to have patience... good luck