This is not quite right. MP materials only produces REE concentrate, not refined rare earths. All of the concentrate produced by MP is sold to refineries in China that produce purified REE oxides and metals.
MP has raised capital to build an REE separation facility over the next couple of years. By comparison, Lynas has been producing refined rare earths for the better part of a decade. Over that time, Lynas survived a long period of weak REE prices, developed new specialized products, lowered costs of production, and established a strong customer base.
MP is a potential challenger to Lynas sort of like the Porsche Taycan was a Tesla killer. Experience and cost of production matter quite a lot in the REE business. It’s important to note that MP is built from the ashes of Molycorp, which invested hundreds of millions of dollars in an REE refinery at the Mountain Pass mine, only to go bankrupt when REE prices fell in 2013. Before that, Molycorp stock went parabolic in speculative fervor when China cut off REE exports to Japan in 2011 in a territorial dispute.
MP Materials is a high profile company as the only REE mine in the US and has done very well building political support and investor interest. It might very well succeed this time around, now that REE prices have recovered and global demand is increasing every year. But as MP is still pre-production, their future profitability in REE refining is pretty uncertain
Overall, I see more upside potential in Lynas stock.
Super, thanks a lot for offering your research. I have a silly question: I see the average volume for OTC ticker is ~300000, does this mean I have to trickle my buys over multiple days if I wanted to get a low 6-figure investment in? Seems totally unreasonable but just wanted to make sure I'm not stepping on a rake.
Last ER transcript here
benchmark pricing was fairly kind to us, but I think that more importantly, it reflects the strength of the key Nd segments into which we sell, particularly new automotive and by that, we're talking about the plug hybrid and electric vehicles. And I know that many investors are looking at Lynas as an excellent way to gain exposure to this electric vehicle and new energy Semantic of course continued growth in renewables, particularly in wind power and electronics.
They are operating at 75% capacity in Malaysia due to both market uncertainty and COVID restrictions in the country. But overall they seem to be in a happy place just because prices went up and they had the biggest revenues in their history so far.
Last edited: