You can install our site as a web app on your iOS device by utilizing the Add to Home Screen feature in Safari. Please see this thread for more details on this.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
As much as I don't want to feed your Crusade of Captain Obvious, I have to say that:it stops in exactly the same distance as the P+ with the same tires.
The tires, not the brakes, determine stopping distance. That's how physics works.
The brakes (AND the tires) determine subjective "feel"
See also the $10,000 brake upgrade kit Porsche offers, that also stops the car in the same distance as the stock brakes when on the same tires.
Now, if you're on a track stopping from 120 mph for the 4th time within a couple of minutes, the smaller/weaker system might start taking longer until they cool.... but bigger brakes can't ever make you stop shorter the first time from any speed you'd drive on a public road.
Hi
I had a great opportunity to buy a brand-new model 3 performance from someone else. Apparently, he needs that money for his business. The car is arriving mid-late next month. Despite ordering the Performance model, I’ve never driven it. I’ve ridden in it. It was amazingly quick as my head was pushed towards the sofa-like head rest.
The dealer that I got the deal from let me drive the model 3 long range dual motors. I was impressed by the swiftness despite its weight. The only downside that stands out to me is the brake. The suspension is a bit loose but not too hard to control. The engine brake is awesome.
Brakes are bad. I mean.. really bad. To give a little bit of my background. I currently own a 991.2 Carrera GTS and a F90 M5 competition. These cars have good brakes. M5 is a bit over 2tons including me and it brakes really well. I know they are in a different class. What I am trying to say is, the brakes feeling of the model 3 feels incredibly loose. It’s like it wouldn’t stop.
I know that it was the LR dual motors. I wonder if the Performance model offers a substantially better brakes. How well do they perform? Is the initial bite more noticeable? Should I get a set of aftermarket brakes like Brembo, Alcon?
Thanks.
The base brakes will stop the car in exactly the same distance as the most expensive high end brake kit you can buy if the tires are the same, because the tires, not the brakes, are what stop the car.
It can't ever make it stop shorter, because physics.
No, the standard brakes will not stop the car in exactly the same distance as a high performance brake set-up due to numerous reasons.
N
A performance brake set-up will allow maximum brake pressure, and thus maximum retardation, to be achieved in a faster time.
This is due to the following;
Reduced hose expansion of braided hoses compared to standard rubber, allowing a faster increase to maximum hydraulic pressure. A rubber brake hose allows more volume change before maximum pressure is achieved.
All these things allow a faster deceleration of the wheel/tyre to the point of maximum friction, and thus a shorter stopping distance.
BTW, I have qualifications in aircraft braking systems and have designed, manufactured and tested high performance brake kits.
As much as I don't want to feed your Crusade of Captain Obvious
A
, I have to say that:
1. You keep coming everywhere talking about stopping distance when people talking about "the feel".
Except, they will.
Because that's how physics works.
This is due to your imagination.
Once you reacht he limit of the tires- which the stock brakes can do exactly as fast as upgraded brakes, then MOAR BRAKES does not slow you any faster
It can't.
Again because that's how physics work
Go read the essay it linked to.
it explains all this in detail- with math and everything.
Factually wrong- and debunked in the essay.
In interest of brevity I cut out your other claims- because again they're almost all specifically debunked as factually wrong in the essay.
Go read it.
Except, they do not.
Again- the essay goes through each element of a braking system- describing what they do and how, and why upgrading them can not reduce your stopping distance.
And the author of the essay that says you're wrong has done so for actual car manufacturers.... and for Stoptech making BBKs.
And teaches SAE master classes on braking system design and funciton.
He has literally written books on this topic
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B08DL3LTYK/ref=dbs_a_def_rwt_hsch_vapi_tkin_p1_i0
His resume seems better than yours.
Also his math, facts, and physics.
But from a strict marketing point of view- if brake upgrades actually stopped you shorter than Stoptech, Brembo, and others would be screaming that fact from the mountains.
Instead Brembos FAQ explicitly tells you they don't even measure normal highway stopping distance because their kits do not reduce it since it's determined by the tires.
Stoptech has numerous white papers saying the same thing.
This is a fallacious argument due to not understanding the subject matter. To make a proper counter argument, you need to detail valid technical points.
A properly designed uprated brake kit will allow you to reach the limit of a tyres maximum grip in a faster time
, and thus reduce total braking distance. I’ve tested this myself.
Absolutely no technical counter argument to the points I posted, yet again, just fallacious words.
Nowhere in the essay did the author discuss the points that I am highlighting
Reduced hose expansion of braided hoses compared to standard rubber, allowing a faster increase to maximum hydraulic pressure. A rubber brake hose allows more volume change before maximum pressure is achieved.
James Walker Jr said:Although those cool-looking stainless steel brake lines alone will not make your car stop any faster, the decrease in compliance and improvement in pedal feel can make a driver much more confident.
Rubbish, it’s because you don't have a valid technical counter argument to those points.
Same again, bit of a theme here.
The problem is, you don’t fully understand what I have written,
You haven’t debunked any of my points with any technical argument. Telling me to read someone else’s info is not an argument.
A simple point here - If you think hydraulic rubber hose flex, and thus the volume increase on the pressure side of the circuit doesn’t delay the point of maximum pressure of a system, then you have absolutely no understanding of how a hydraulic system works
Brembo FAQ said:At the speeds that stopping distance is generally measured from (60 to 70mph), the test is primarily testing the tire's grip on the pavement.
As delivered from the manufacturer, nearly all vehicles are able to engage the ABS or lock the wheels at these speeds. Therefore, an increase in braking power will do nothing to stop the vehicle in a shorter distance.
For this reason, we do not record stopping distances at this time.
“You can take this one to the bank. Regardless of your huge rotor diameter, brake pedal ratio, magic brake pad material, or number of pistons in your calipers, your maximum deceleration is limited every time by the tire to road interface. That is the point of this whole article.
Your brakes do not stop your car. Your tires do stop the car. So while changes to different parts of the brake system may affect certain characteristics or traits of the system behavior, using stickier tires is ultimately the only sure-fire method of decreasing stopping distances.”
Road and Track said:If you want your car to stop faster, an intuitive start may be to upgrade your brakes. While it may sound logical, for everyday driving it will probably have no effect on your actual stopping distance.
Clive is pointing out that better braking components influence the responsiveness of the system the computer is trying to control, and that influences the ability of the computer to achieve optimal braking performance... and thus given the same tires, better braking components can still lead to material improvements in braking performance.
And that doesn't even get into "does the computer actually have a panic-stop setup, or just ABS that still requires the driver to apply enough pressure to get to the threshhold" (an issue at high speed for marginal brakes)
He's claiming that.
But failing to offer any evidence of it.
In contrast to 4 different sources now (including Brembo, Stoptech, Road and Track, and a guy who designs OEM car maker braking systems) all saying he's wrong.
I'm unaware of any OEM vehicle in at least 20 years where the stock brakes were so marginal a panic stop could not engage ABS by smashing the brake pedal.
Certainly not any Tesla has made.
Are you aware of such a vehicle?
I think the point you are missing is the initial ramp up time to get to full traction. With stiffer brake lines, calipers, (and firewall!) this occurs in a shorter time, which inevitably means a shorter stopping distance.
We should just do real world testing instead of bench racing. Someone send me a big brake kit and I’ll find another P3D on PS4S to do some testing with