Should I replace the tire ?

[ksadp]

Hit the curb on my model Y . Rim is dented but much worried about the crack on the sidewall of the tire . Should I replace the tire ?

 

[SteveFromNY]

Same thing happened to my wife's truck and she brought it to get checked. Turns out she needed a replacement on the spot, so I would get that looked at. You don't want to find out while driving!

 

[ksadp]

Same thing happened to my wife's truck and she brought it to get checked. Turns out she needed a replacement on the spot, so I would get that looked at. You don't want to find out while driving!

Thanks. I have an appointment with Tesla next week . The can and tire is brand new

 

[SteveFromNY]

good luck! too bad you arent closer because I'm considering selling my new gemini wheels/covers and tires.

 

[fiehlsport]

Can you see steel belt through the damage? If not, you're fine.

I highly doubt that needs replacement. You just cracked a layer of cosmetic rubber.

 

[DanDi58]

Hit the curb on my model Y . Rim is dented but much worried about the crack on the sidewall of the tire . Should I replace the tire ? View attachment 915443

Is a $300 tire worth the life of your family?

 

[SteveFromNY]

Is a $300 tire worth the life of your family?

agreed! dont end up on wham bam tesla cam.

 

[richyrich]

There’s nothing unique to Tesla wheels or tires - you can go to any tire shop and get this looked at.

 

[ksadp]

Is a $300 tire worth the life of your family?

No . I am most definitely changing it .

 

[Pianewman]

Don't wait for a Tesla SC visit. Go to Discount Tire.

 

[240vPlug]

Is a $300 tire worth the life of your family?

This! Get the tire replaced. No reason to risk your life and the lives of others on the road to save $300.

 

[HenryR]

I have a small flap on my sidewall near the rim. I took it to Tesla. They said it was just cosmetic, no threads or belts were visible. I think I’m going to replace it anyway. I understand that you have to replace both tires on the same axle, so it’s $600+, not $300 as some have said.

 

[DanDi58]

I have a small flap on my sidewall near the rim. I took it to Tesla. They said it was just cosmetic, no threads or belts were visible. I think I’m going to replace it anyway. I understand that you have to replace both tires on the same axle, so it’s $600+, not $300 as some have said.

See post #6

 

[Pianewman]

I have a small flap on my sidewall near the rim. I took it to Tesla. They said it was just cosmetic, no threads or belts were visible. I think I’m going to replace it anyway. I understand that you have to replace both tires on the same axle, so it’s $600+, not $300 as some have said.

Photo would help. How many miles on your tires?
Details.

 

[HenryR]

I have 2800 miles

 

[Chewy13]

I have a small flap on my sidewall near the rim. I took it to Tesla. They said it was just cosmetic, no threads or belts were visible. I think I’m going to replace it anyway. I understand that you have to replace both tires on the same axle, so it’s $600+, not $300 as some have said.

Sounds like a tire shop looking to make money.
Especially on a new car, the other tire is basically new and there’s no sense in replacing both.

On a set of tires that have been well driven, it really depends on how much is left on the other tire. Traction can vary in inclement weather, but if you’re on a tight budget - it’s not required to replace both tires. Your car will still go down the road, and work just fine.

If you’re below the legal limit, the tire shop can refuse to work on your car, at least in MA I believe that’s the case.

 

[Pianewman]

HenryR: Tread depth measurement is more important than internet advice. A close examination by a qualified tire shop is also critical.

Without a photo, we have no idea what you're talking about.