John in LB
Member
Geico has truly provided great service for us over 40 years. We have had 2 or 3 fender benders over the years and they have done well by us (I can't say about major accidents, as I don't have experience). What is best is the 24/7 customer service.Personally I would not insure with either of those. Price should not be the only factor, when you need insurance to work like a bad accident you will be glad you have a top carrier. Some ill throw yo under the bus and others will cancel you.
I check pricing periodically, but as I said we have been with them for 40 years... so, their pricing is always very competitive for our family.