There were some interesting arguments made over whether $2500 (or $2000) was fair for supercharging back with the Model S 60. Personally, I think it's worth 2000 simply to future proof escalating energy costs. I do not think it is remotely possible to make the case that free supercharging is worth $5000. I would just as soon keep my free supercharging, but I can't. That would be an absurd financial decision. Oh well. I too would have taken a credit toward a future purchase or even free FSD (which may not arrive before the car wears out). Tesla needs to hire an unintended consequences czar to evaluate these knee-jerk moves in advance.