I was doing a bit of estimation math of my own... 50,000 units with a bit more than half (or more) of them in the US in 2015, with an acceleration toward 2018. In 2014, 55% of units were sold in the US, and they produced 35,000 cars. So your 2014 number should be roughly 19k or so. In 2015, that would represent 27,500 (not 14,500 that you estimate). A ramp-up of the factory will result in more numbers, especially as line 2 begins operating at peak efficiency... I'm guessing by 2017 they can get 75k-100k vehicles, which would give us 40k-50k per year in the US. By that time, in early '18, the Model 3 triggers the phase-out in the first few ten-thousand or so.
Note my comment is when the phase-out is started (200k is hit), not when the credit isn't available anymore.
I agree with you that the Model 3 will trigger the phase-out - "the first few thousand" or so is what I had figured.
You seem to misunderstand the significance of the formatting of this line
2015 Aug 54,000 (14,500 for 2015 + prior years)
That is 14,500 from
Monthly Plug-In Sales Scorecard which is the best historical number you can get without waiting for a quarterly conference call. You seem to be assuming that I'm doing some sort of estimate of that number when I'm just pulling existing data.
again
the actual data is
US running total Tesla Sales vs 200,000 for federal credit phase out trigger
2011 end 1,900 (roadster 1900)
2012 end 4,550 (2,650 Model S for 2012 + prior year (1900 roadster))
2013 end 22,200 (17,650 for 2013 + prior years (the 22,200 was correct, had a typo of 14,650 but did the math with 17,650)
2014 end 39,500 (17,300 for 2014 + prior years)
2015 Aug 54,000 (14,500 for 2015 + prior years)
now from Sept 2015 forward you can toss in your estimates.
Are you saying you expect Tesla to deliver 13,000 cars between Sept 1 2015 and Dec 31 2015? Assuming you do that gets you to 27,500 for 2015 and to 49,500 for the 2011 to 2015 total.
Then you say you expect 40,000 to 50,000 in 2017. That takes us to 89,500 to 99,500 at end of 2017 without 2016 in the mix.
For that to run out the credit 2016 would have to produce twice as much as 2017 in your scenario. Do you see the disconnect?
Even if 2016 gets the same 50,000 then that leaves another 50,000+ for 2018 and then another 6 months of sales to make it over 100,000 model 3s with the full credit.
Leave out the world numbers and stick to the US and tell me what you expect for 2016 and 2017 if I've misunderstood your math.
Even if you and I are in agreement on the ramp up I feel it is worth it to make these numbers clear to others that don't realize it phases out. Too many posts use terminology that make it sound to the uninformed like a hard cutoff.