Maybe, but many people think the S is a boat and I tend to agree with them. Way too big for my liking. Even if it was the same price as a Model 3, I would buy a Model 3. But I might be an outlier.
I am of the same opinion - way too big on my test drive. I could feel the inertia of the huge weight in acceleration. I am looking for nimble and should get that in the 3.