So I'm probably looking at this through a *somewhat* unique prism, but the low mileage is important to me (as is build date within the last 15 months.) My thinking is I'd rather spend an extra $5-10K to get a CPO in pristine shape, and the odds having little/no paint defects decrease significantly above 10-20K miles. I would actually expand my artificial build date cutoff if it was low mileage. For instance, this P85+ was a December 2013 build. Very low miles, and every single option except (oddly) it has a body color roof.
85 kWh Performance Model S P26370 | Tesla Motors
That's a great deal, just wish it had the pano. Plus it will cost me around $2K to bring it here. Obviously I'm not the typical "great deal it was under $60K!" buyer, but rather my definition is "exactly what I was looking for at a fair price." I know I'm setting myself up to pay a premium relative to other CPO listings, and that's OK. The most important thing is to get a great car that is exactly what I want. i've waited a long time to reward myself with this purchase.
UNRELATED ASIDE...or maybe not - last night I booked four tickets for our family vacation. I have never in my life paid full price for an upgrade. I've accepted them as comp for getting bumped, I've "purchased" an upgrade at a steep discount with miles, I've paid a nominal fee ($25-50) at the gate to move up....but retail is for suckers. And last night I stared at my computer screen for 10 minutes before clicking that non-refundable upgrade button. It was like piling money on the table and lighting it on fire. For what? So we only have to share the bathroom with four other people? To be in the extra leg room front row? To save a couple seconds getting onto and off from the plane? A free drink and peanuts? That's worth how much?
It's not that much of a hardship to fly coach. Except I've been flying discount fares for 35 years, and I'm kind of tired of it. So what the heck, I can afford it, not like I'm postponing retirement or sending the kid to community college, splurge once in awhile for a change. So I did.
This car, even at CPO prices, is a major splurge in my life. I'm not really interested in a rock bottom deal. I want EXACTLY what I want, with no compromises - or at least compromises (gently used, low mileage) I can live with. But that's just me, it's only applicable to me and my situation, and I think there have been some great points made in this thread about what these CPO listings maybe should or may one day be priced.
ETA - FTR, those brats are flying economy on the return leg. I haven't completely lost my mind.